Capex ramped, earnings stumbled; transmission delays push renewables to FY28
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 6/10
Grade B
Missed prior renewable FY27 guidance (1.5→1.2 GW); reason (transmission delays) is external but execution slipped. Nabha accretion and capex track record solid.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Q1 missed PAT (-10.8% YoY) despite revenue barely growing (+2.8%). Renewable capacity guidance trimmed (1.5→1.2 GW FY27) due to transmission delays, though multi-year pipeline intact. Nabha acquisition (₹1,000 Cr EBITDA p.a.) and sustained capex (₹10,000 Cr FY27) support long-term, but near-term headwinds (LNG USD20, battery competition, tax rate rise to 28%) cap upside.
₹8124.1 Cr
Revenue · +2.8% YoY₹661.9 Cr
Reported PAT · −10.8% YoYCompressing
Margins · vs guidance: MixedDid the claims hold up?
Thermal generation resilient despite elevated gas prices
OVERSTATEDAdjusted thermal PBT down ₹123 Cr YoY; merchant sales & LNG trading lower ₹87 Cr; LNG at USD20/MMBtu constraining sales to 2–3 hrs/day peak market
Distribution segment added ₹71 Cr incremental profit
MET₹41 Cr from regulatory carrying cost, ₹19 Cr from operations (ROE/ROCE boost, tariff increases), ₹11 Cr from new transmission; volumes up 4% YoY (guidance was 5–6% demand growth)
1.2 GW renewable capacity to commission in FY27
OVERSTATEDDown from prior guidance of 1.2–1.5 GW; now 1.0–1.2 GW. Reason: transmission line ROW delays (external). Phased to FY28 (1.4–1.6 GW). Multi-year plan (4.6 GW) intact
Capex run rate accelerated in line with Q3 FY26
METQ1 capex ₹2,300 Cr (6.5x YoY vs ₹355 Cr Q1 FY26); ₹10,000 Cr guided for FY27 RE projects (vs ₹1,200 Cr in Q4 FY26). Capex acceleration validated
Gas merchant power competitive vs battery on long-term basis
PartialManagement projects gas variable cost ₹4–4.5 (at $6–$8/MMBtu) vs ₹5–5.5 battery (₹2–2.5 solar + ₹3 battery). But current LNG USD20 makes only high-DAM sales viable for 2–3 hrs/day
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
Renewable FY27 capacity target trimmed
DowngradePrior guidance 1.2–1.5 GW → now 1.0–1.2 GW. Phased to FY28 (1.4–1.6 GW) due to transmission line delays (ROW issues, PGCIL-led). Multi-year (4.6 GW) intact.
Merchant power EBITDA lower ₹87 Cr
DowngradeLNG prices remain elevated (USD20/MMBtu). Market access limited to high-DAM peak hours (2–3 hrs/day). Structural headwind, not a quarter-specific anomaly.
Tax rate step-up to 28%
DowngradeSection 80-IA tax holiday expired for some units. Permanent increase from 25% → 28%. No offset announced.
Nabha Power acquisition closed
UpgradeClosed June 25, 2026; ₹15 Cr profit in 5 days (immaterial in Q1). Expected ₹1,000 Cr EBITDA annually on steady state. Material accretion (₹250 Cr quarterly run-rate).
Capex acceleration maintained
UpgradeQ1 capex ₹2,300 Cr (6.5x YoY); ₹10,000 Cr guided for FY27. In line with prior 'accelerated run rate' guidance. Execution strong.
Distribution franchise expansion timeline extended
NeutralUP franchise now expected post-election (was originally targeted earlier). Possible Maharashtra traction. No concrete near-term closures.
The Q&A
Analysts pressed hard on transmission delays (Satyadeep Jain, Shirom Kapur) and battery competition (Apoorva Bahadur, Sumit Kishore). Management held firm on 1.0–1.2 GW FY27 target 'after factoring in all those issues,' acknowledging ROW bottlenecks but not retreating. Q&A tone: defensive but transparent. No evasion, but also no new upside surprises.
Nabha Power accretion — Mohit Kumar, ICICI Securities
Answered5 days operation = ₹15 Cr profit booked. Gross debt added ₹6–6.5 Cr (₹3 Cr Nabha book, ₹3.8 Cr Torrent book). Steady-state EBITDA ₹1,000 Cr annually.
Renewable EBITDA lower despite generation up — Mohit Kumar, ICICI Securities
AnsweredPrior year Q1 had ₹47 Cr LPS (late payment surcharge) income, unavailable this quarter. Excluding that, EBITDA up ₹66 Cr on standalone basis.
Distribution circle demand slump — Satyadeep Jain, Ambit Capital
AnsweredAhmedabad benchmark to national average. Surat/Dahej industrial, growth naturally lower. DNHDD exceptional (one-off). AT&C losses up in Agra (prior year had special collections reducing loss).
Merchant power and battery risk — Satyadeep Jain, Ambit Capital
PartialPeak demand always present; period prolonging. Summer demand supports merchant sales for untied capacity. Long-term gas at $6–$8/MMBtu competitive vs battery. Current USD20 temporary.
Renewable project delays and transmission — Satyadeep Jain, Ambit Capital
AnsweredTransmission line availability is bottleneck (ROW issues, PGCIL delays). After factoring these issues, 1.2 GW target is reasonable estimate; will update quarterly if risks materialize.
Renewable commissioning phase-out FY27 — Sumit Kishore, Axis Capital
AnsweredQ1: 70 MW. Q2: ~400 MW. H2: ~800 MW. Total ~1.2 GW on track.
Amgen plant replacement plans — Sumit Kishore, Axis Capital
PartialLand not yet finalized, may not be Gujarat. Coal allocation pending central govt approval. Work-in-progress; firm plan once coal approved.
Renewable bidding philosophy and C&I opportunities — Sumit Kishore, Axis Capital
AnsweredParticipate almost all bids but restrict to mid-teen IRR minimum. Benchmark is IRR, not capacity acquisition. Disciplined approach continues.
Gas power vs battery competitiveness — Apoorva Bahadur, IIFL
AnsweredVariable cost ₹4–4.5 (at $6–$8/MMBtu) vs ₹5–5.5 battery (solar + storage). Gas competitive long-term. Cannot hedge gas prices long-term, so no PPA strategy with C&I/data centers.
LPS income renewal vs FY26 baseline — Shirom Kapur, Jefferies
AnsweredQ1 LPS ₹46 Cr; same for full FY26. All ₹46 Cr was in Q1 FY26. Unlikely full-year FY27.
Capacity pipeline delays (SECI 12, SECI 16, hybrid) — Shirom Kapur, Jefferies
AnsweredTransmission line availability is primary driver. Plan execution around transmission line commissioning to avoid capex ahead of transmission.
Nabha PLF and salary cost reduction — Shirom Kapur, Jefferies
AnsweredNabha typically 85% PLF. Salary cost reduction likely one-off from capitalization of salary costs, not structural.
LNG availability and contracts — Atul Tiwari, JPMorgan
Answered3 cargos for summer demand acquired and being used. Spot cargo USD20 (not affordable). FY27+ have 10-cargo contract linked to Brent (not spot). Import selectively for price/demand alignment.
Total capex Q1 breakdown — Atul Tiwari, JPMorgan
Answered₹2,300 Cr total. RE: ₹1,550 Cr. Thermal coal: ₹125 Cr. Transmission: ₹120 Cr. Distribution: ₹500 Cr.
Franchise distribution pipeline (UP, Maharashtra) — Harsh Singh, Sameeksha Capital
PartialUP expected post-election. Maharashtra possibly. No concrete franchises right now.
High-DAM merchant market dynamics — Vishal, PL Capital
AnsweredUSD20 variable cost ₹13; regular market capped ₹10. Only high-DAM viable, 2–3 hrs/day, not continuous. Very challenging. Flexibilization investments enable this model.
Guidance
No explicit FY27 revenue target; capex implies 5–10% capacity growth
Medium4.6 GW renewable pipeline + Nabha (₹1,000 Cr EBITDA) + distribution growth; overall capacity mix supports mid-single-digit revenue CAGR, but LNG prices and merchant power headwinds offset.
No explicit OPM/NPM guidance; tax rate permanently 28% (vs 25% prior)
MediumOPM likely stable 18–19% (distribution high-margin, thermal pressured). NPM capped by 28% tax rate; PAT conversion weaker than prior years despite operational improvements.
FY27: ~₹10,000 Cr for renewable projects (₹1,550 Cr incurred Q1)
HighAccelerated run-rate validated by Q1 (₹2,300 Cr all capex). Transmission ₹120 Cr, distribution ₹500 Cr, thermal ₹125 Cr; RE bulk.
Risks the call surfaced
Merchant power margin compression
HighLNG spot at USD20/MMBtu; variable cost ₹13 vs regular market cap ₹10. Only viable in high-DAM 2–3 hrs/day. Merchant sales ₹87 Cr lower YoY. Battery competition rising.
Renewable capacity execution risk
MediumFY27 renewable target reduced 1.5 GW → 1.2 GW due to transmission line delays (ROW issues, PGCIL-led). SECI 12, SECI 16 wind projects extended to FY28. Capex is committed but timing slipped.
Tax rate structural increase
MediumSection 80-IA tax holiday expired for some units; effective tax rate stepped from 25% to 28%. Permanent structural headwind on PAT conversion; no mitigation announced.
Distribution franchise expansion delays
LowUP franchise tender expected post-election (timeline vague). Maharashtra traction unclear. Limits near-term distribution growth acceleration above +4% volume growth.
Demand growth slower than expected
LowDistribution volumes +4% YoY vs prior guidance of 5–6% power demand growth. Ahmedabad (10%) is benchmark; industrial areas (Surat, Dahej) showing muted growth. Risk if national demand disappoints.
Management
Score 7/10. CFO transparent on headwinds (LNG prices, transmission delays, battery competition); avoids hype. Candid on constraints (cannot hedge gas long-term, no C&I gas PPAs). Defensive tone appropriate to delivered misses. Capex acceleration validated (₹2,300 Cr Q1, ₹10,000 Cr FY27 on track). Renewable capacity slipped (1.5→1.2 GW FY27) due to transmission delays (external factor), but multi-year pipeline intact. Nabha accretion (₹1,000 Cr EBITDA) delivered on time.
1 · Q2 FY27 (Sep 2026)
400 MW renewable commissioned (vs 70 MW Q1); Nabha full-quarter contribution ramping
2 · H2 FY27 (Oct–Mar 2027)
800 MW renewable commissioning; Solapur transmission expected operational
3 · FY28 (Apr 2027+)
1.4–1.6 GW renewable commissioned; Nabha EBITDA fully embedded
Nabha acquisition (₹1,000 Cr EBITDA p.a.) and sustained capex (₹10,000 Cr FY27) support long-term, but near-term headwinds (LNG USD20, battery competition, tax rate rise to 28%) cap upside.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.