Growth intact, margins squeezed; capacity ramp delayed to FY28
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 6/10
Grade B
First earnings call post-IPO; FY24-FY26 track record strong (58.8% revenue CAGR, PAT CAGR ~95%); no prior numeric guidance to miss against.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Strong 35% YoY revenue growth and structural tailwinds (circular economy, LME listing, 51% capacity expansion) offset by 260-bps margin compression, conservative FY27 guidance (10-20% volume growth, ~10% EBITDA margin), and delayed capacity utilization to FY28. Near-term headwinds (geopolitical disruption, procurement challenges, commodity exposure) cap upside; long-term positioning remains sound.
₹338.8 Cr
Revenue · +35.2% YoY₹19.9 Cr
Reported PAT · +6% YoYCompressing
Margins · vs guidance: CorroboratedDid the claims hold up?
EBITDA margin 10% in Q1 FY27
MET₹33.8 Cr EBITDA ÷ ₹338.8 Cr revenue = 9.97% (round 10%)
35.2% YoY revenue growth
MET₹338.8 Cr vs ₹250.6 Cr Q1 FY26 = 35.2% growth
Capacity expansion 50.9% effective May 29, 2026
MET1,56,950 MTPA vs prior 1,04,025 MTPA = 50.9% increase confirmed
Export revenue grew to ₹465 Cr in FY26 from ₹81.6 Cr FY24
MET471% growth stated; Q1 FY27 exports 38.7% of ₹338.8 = ₹131 Cr run-rate
Volume decline Q4→Q1 due to geopolitical and procurement disruptions
METQ1 volume 17,645 MT at 65% utilization; management cited war impact, import blockages
Margin pressure from raw material and petroleum cost inflation
METGross profit per ton fell ₹38,000 (Q4) → ₹34,500 (Q1); EBITDA per ton ₹19,000 vs prior ₹20,000+
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
Margin outlook downgraded
DowngradeFY26 EBITDA margin 12.6% → Q1 FY27 10%; FY27E ~10% (vs 12%+ prior expectations). Driven by ₹4,500/ton gross profit decline and petroleum/raw material inflation.
Volume growth guidance conservative
NewFY27 guidance 10-20% (vs historical 58.8% CAGR FY24-26). Management citing geopolitical disruption, procurement challenges, not market demand weakness.
Capacity utilization timeline extended
New70-75% optimum pushed to FY28 (not FY27) despite 51% capacity addition in May. Current 65% utilization held due to market caution.
Export growth reaffirmed
MaintainedExports grew to ₹465 Cr FY26 (up from ₹81.6 Cr FY24); Q1 FY27 exports 38.7% of revenue. LME listing (announced this period) new credential.
The Q&A
Analysts pushed back on conservative 10-20% volume guidance given strong historical growth and new capacity, questioning if management was under-guiding. Management held firm, citing sustained geopolitical uncertainty and Middle East trade blockages; willing to 'overperform' but chose caution over optimism.
Volume decline Q4→Q1 — Aniket Madhwani, Steptrade Capital
AnsweredWar-driven import disruptions and procurement challenges forced strategic conservative positioning; capacity still ramping, utilization 65% vs 70-75% optimal.
Customer concentration — Vivek Jhala, Jhala Family Office
AnsweredConcentration already fell 70% → 40%; will continue declining as company grows. Top 5 customers will remain ~max business; structure inherent to the industry.
Working capital deployment — Vivek Jhala, Jhala Family Office
AnsweredMostly for scrap sourcing from new geographies and developing export origins (higher credit). Sustainable WC cycle 90-100 days; gross requirement ₹400+ Cr FY27.
ROCE dilution from new equity — Vivek Jhala, Jhala Family Office
PartialHistorically low capex = high ROCE; new equity will dilute ratios. Target to maintain 20%+ range long-term despite balance-sheet expansion.
Margin outlook — Nishita, Sapphire Capital
AnsweredGeopolitical scenario ongoing; safer to guide ~10% for full FY27 rather than 13%.
Hedging effectiveness — Anirudh Sharma, Ekaant Investments
AnsweredWorks efficiently; daily audit system, no positions left unhedged, zero margin impact from unhedged commodity exposure.
Procurement cost and volume guidance credibility — Dhairya Trivedi, DJT Corporation
AnsweredBeing conservative; willing to overperform. Whole 20% is volume-only (no metal price growth); supply-chain caution. Targeting ~85,000 MT FY27 vs 70,600 MT Q1.
Lithium-ion battery recycling — Aniket Madhwani, Steptrade Capital
AnsweredNothing concrete; evaluating multiple opportunities. Lithium is one but no direct entry planned now.
Domestic procurement diversification — Arvind Arora, A Square Capital
PartialAlready started participating in corporate auctions and direct buys. Challenges include higher domestic prices, GST complexity, unorganized sector. Working on it.
Lead alloys growth — Ankur Gulati, Genuity Capital
AnsweredRunning ~30-35% growth. OEM approvals slow ramp; gradual scaling. Capacity reallocation between pure lead and alloys ongoing.
Guidance
FY27 +10% to +20% volume growth
MediumVolume-driven only; no metal price appreciation. FY26 baseline ₹1,167.7 Cr implies ₹1,285-1,401 Cr FY27. Targeting ~85,000 MT FY27 (from 70,600 MT Q1 = ~282K MT FY26 annualized base).
EBITDA margin ~10% FY27
MediumDown from 12.6% FY26. Geopolitical impact (freight, import costs) expected to persist; room for recovery if macro stabilizes but not in base case.
No major capex FY27
High₹15 Cr brownfield done; new land (5.56 acres) for future phases, not immediate deployment. Exploring opportunities on new land but no concrete timelines.
Risks the call surfaced
Geopolitical supply-chain
HighWar-driven Middle East blockages and trade cost inflation constraining volumes and margins. Management cited as primary reason for conservative FY27 guidance despite 35% YoY growth.
Customer concentration
MediumLargest customer reduced from 70% to ~40%, top 5 always ~max business. Industry structure (few large OEM relationships) inherent but concentration remains.
Commodity price exposure
MediumBusiness inherently commodity-linked (lead spot prices). Back-to-back hedging mechanism works but basis risk, timing gaps, or unhedged pockets could impact profitability.
Capacity utilization ramp delay
MediumDespite ₹1.57L MTPA installed capacity (May 2026), only 65% utilized in Q1; management expects 70-75% optimum by FY28, not FY27. Implies near-term margin pressure from fixed-cost deleverage.
Margin recovery uncertainty
MediumQ1 EBITDA margin 10% vs 12.6% FY26. FY27 guidance still ~10%; no recovery built in unless geopolitical situation improves. Raw material (domestic) and petroleum cost inflation blamed.
Management
Score 7/10. Clear, transparent on challenges. Candid about geopolitical headwinds, margin pressure, capacity ramp delays. Did not spin or over-promise; chose conservative guidance despite strong track record. Strong FY24-26 track record: 58.8% revenue CAGR, PAT grew 9 Cr → 84.7 Cr. Q1 FY27 confirmed ₹338.8 Cr revenue and ₹19.9 Cr PAT aligned with actual. On guidance: capacity expansion delivered on-budget (₹15 Cr) in May.
1 · H2 FY27
Seasonal upside; management 'more confident' on H2 amid supply-chain normalization hopes
2 · FY28
Capacity utilization ramps to optimum 70-75%; margin recovery if commodity costs stabilize
3 · 2026-27
Domestic scrap sourcing diversification to reduce import dependency and freight exposure
Near-term headwinds (geopolitical disruption, procurement challenges, commodity exposure) cap upside; long-term positioning remains sound.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.