Growth returns, but grape costs crimp margins sharply
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 7/10
Grade B
Met revenue and PAT guidance. Gross margin recovery timeline vague; grape cost normalization deferred to Q4-Q1 FY28.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Revenue recovery to +4.1% and PAT growth of 34% signal a turning point after two flat years, but gross margin compression of 280 bps—driven by locked-in high grape costs and unfavorable procurement mix—undercuts the momentum. Management's target recovery to prior-year EBITDA margins by year-end FY27 is at risk; near-term relief is not credible until Q4 harvest.
₹145.4 Cr
Revenue · +4.1% YoY₹8.1 Cr
Reported PAT · +34.4% YoYCompressing
Margins · vs guidance: MixedDid the claims hold up?
Net revenue growing by 4%, net profit rising 34% YoY
METRevenue +4.1% YoY, PAT +34.4% YoY; both corroborated
EBITDA increasing 8% YoY
UnverifiedEBITDA growth 8% claimed; not independently verified from delivered P&L
Wine tourism contribution increased by 220 bps YoY to nearly 20%
OVERSTATEDPrior guidance 13%, now 20% (+700 bps, not 220); faster ramp than expected
Gross profit declined 280 basis points versus last year
METOPM 18.9%; gross margin compression acknowledged as 280 bps from grape costs
Three consecutive quarters of positive revenue growth
METQ2 FY27 +4.1%, QoQ +20.4%; pattern consistent with recovery narrative
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
Wine tourism revenue ramp
UpgradePrior guidance 13% of revenue. Q2 achieved 20% (+700 bps, not 220 as claimed). Haven occupancy and room revenue up 32% YoY, Vintage Room now operational.
Grape cost normalization timeline
DowngradePrior: costs to normalize Q4 FY27. Now: 150 bps headwind persists through Q3, only moderate Q4, full normalization Q1 FY28. Procurement locked into long-term contracts.
Elite/premium contribution
UpgradeReached 82% of sales (up 420 bps YoY). The Source grew 30% YoY, Merlot 100%+ YoY. Premiumization thesis delivering, but diluted by regional mix shift (Telangana lower-margin growth).
Net debt trajectory
UpgradeDown to ₹306 Cr from ₹355 Cr YoY (-14%). Debt-to-EBITDA below 3x. Cash generation improving despite capex (Vintage Room, hotel prep).
The Q&A
Analysts pressed hard on three fronts: (1) timeline to margin recovery amid locked-in grape contracts (management hedged, cited Q4 relief but no guarantee); (2) wine tourism valuation risk (management deflected, saying not relevant 'right now', prices will normalize); (3) regional concentration risk and state policy headwinds in Haryana/Delhi (management acknowledged risks but remained optimistic on 3-year trajectory). Overall: moderate pressure, management held line but offered little concrete on margin recovery path.
Drought and grape costs — Kaustav Bubna, Kamana Holdings
AnsweredLast year's drought cut grape harvest severely; this year expects bumper harvest and cheaper table grapes. But locked into long-term contracts at high prices. Impact not much on premium wines (contracted), but popular segment will see relief.
Telangana growth and market size — Nikhil Upadhaya, SIMPL
AnsweredTelangana delivered 40% YoY and now #2 market. Elite/premium is INR 400 Cr, Sula ~70-75% share. Overall market INR 1000+ Cr. Growth to continue but won't be 40% 'forever'.
EBITDA and margin recovery — Keshav Garg, Counter Cyclical PMS
PartialGrape costs are peak. Raw material 1000 bps higher than own brand growth. Q3-Q4 expected to ease. Immediate goal 22-23% margin over next couple of years; 25-26% long-term.
Gross margin drivers and mix — Nikhil Upadhaya, SIMPL (follow-up)
PartialResorts have higher intrinsic margins; wine mix improving toward elite/premium (82%). Raw material and packing pressures easing. Things 'looking pretty good' but no growth guarantee.
Raw material sourcing and table grape price shock — Siddharth Bhattacharya, Autham Infrastructure
AnsweredTable grape prices went from INR 15-20/kg to INR 30/kg. Last year we bought fewer to cut inventory carryover. This year forced to buy higher-priced grapes due to growth. Typical mix 75-80% wine, 20-25% table grapes.
Guidance
FY27 three-quarter positive revenue growth sustained
MediumQ2 +4.1% YoY; Q1 +1-2% implied. Rate deceleration vs prior quarters; momentum slowing. Wine tourism offsetting core wine weakness.
Recovery to prior-year EBITDA margins by FY27 year-end
LowGrape costs to persist Q2-Q3, moderate Q4, normalize Q1 FY28. Timeline extended; risks to recovery. 22-23% margin target over next couple years; 25-26% long-term (vague).
Grape cost impact to subside Q4 FY27, fully normalize Q1 FY28
MediumBumper harvest 2027 expected to bring cheaper table grapes. Procurement locked into 10-12 year contracts at ₹15-20/kg, so full relief gradual. Near-term risk if rains fail.
Fourth hotel at York (₹25 Cr capex) to open Q4 FY28; 35-key property, 20% room capacity increase
MediumPlanning phase; construction to begin Q4 FY27 post winery relocation. Vintage Room already operational (supporting H2 FY27 revenue).
Risks the call surfaced
Commodity cost lock-in
HighGrape prices locked into 10-12 year contracts at ₹15-20/kg. Table grape prices spiked to ₹30/kg in Harvest 2026. Company cannot reduce costs until procurement resets in Jan-Mar 2027. 150 bps gross margin headwind persisting through Q3.
Regional concentration
HighElite/premium concentrated in Maharashtra, Karnataka, Telangana. Maharashtra still recovering from Pune Porsche incident (3+ quarters of pressure). Karnataka subdued due to beer excise policy. Telangana fast-growing but new, unproven. Policy changes (excise, quota) can derail regional performance.
Popular segment weakness
MediumPopular/economy portfolio (40% of sales) under pressure from indiscriminate discounting by competitors. Company cannot cut prices due to long-term contracts locking grape costs. Margin compression will persist until costs normalize. Growth in this segment de-accelerating.
Wine tourism valuation risk
MediumWine tourism growing to 20% of revenue with high intrinsic margins, but management deflected on demerit of stock valuations. Haven occupancy ramping but competing Alcobev stocks already priced for high tourism multiples. Valuation reset risk if margins don't deliver.
Margin recovery timeline risk
MediumPrior guidance: recovery to prior-year EBITDA margins by FY27 year-end. Updated: costs to persist Q2-Q3, moderate Q4, fully normalize Q1 FY28. Long-term margin target 25-26% (vs current 20.3%) lacks specificity and mechanism. If sales growth slows before costs ease, margin recovery at risk.
Management
Score 6/10. Clear on operational metrics (revenue, PAT, segment growth). Defensive on margin recovery timeline and wine tourism valuation. Some evasion on long-term targets (25-26% margin goal vague, no CAGR). Transparent on challenges (grape costs, regional risks) but offered limited mitigation detail. Met Q2 revenue (+4.1%) and PAT (+34.4%) targets. Wine tourism ramped ahead of guidance (20% vs 13%). Gross margin recovery delayed; FY27 year-end target at risk. Track record: competent but not beating guidance on profitability metrics.
1 · Q3 FY27
Grape cost moderation expected; cheaper table grapes from bumper harvest
2 · Q4 FY27
Vintage Room event venue operational; fourth hotel construction begins
3 · Q4 FY28
Fourth hotel (35-key, ₹25 Cr capex) opens; wine tourism capacity +20%
Management's target recovery to prior-year EBITDA margins by year-end FY27 is at risk; near-term relief is not credible until Q4 harvest.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.