Print anchor steady, but newsprint/forex headwinds cap upside
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 6/10
Grade B
Met FY26 guidance (OTTplay exit, radio rationalization, print focus). Transparent on headwinds. But major shareholder dissent on capital raise impacts trust.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Neutral
multi-year
Print fundamentals intact with pricing power (15% ad growth via yield). But 7.8% overall revenue growth is modest, and newsprint costs at $650-700/MT are at historic peak with no forward hedging—a structural margin risk. Preferential share issuance at ₹24 vs ₹70 book value has triggered shareholder rebellion, signaling governance concerns. No growth thesis articulated beyond cost discipline.
₹197.2 Cr
Revenue · +7.8% YoY₹51.2 Cr
Reported PAT · +399.7% YoYExpanding
Margins · vs guidance: CorroboratedDid the claims hold up?
Print advertising revenue growing year-on-year
METPrint ad revenue grew 15% YoY; majority driven by yield/pricing, not volume
Circulation revenue remaining resilient
METEnglish circulation grew 14% (₹13 Cr vs ₹12 Cr prior year); mostly pricing, minimal copy growth
Profitability improving in tandem with revenue
METPAT 399.7% YoY but from trough; NPM 21% is healthy, but base FY26 Q1 was deeply unprofitable
Elevated newsprint prices are main cost concern
METNewsprint 25-40% of bill-of-material; at $650-700/MT, highest post-COVID; dollar at lifetime high doubles impact
Digital revenue moderated due to portfolio reset
METDigital revenue down 28% YoY; operating EBITDA negative ₹3 Cr (margin -12%)
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
OTTplay discontinued March 2026
WithdrawnPrior FY26 guidance stated OTTplay would be evaluated. Now exited, removing ₹10s Cr annual losses. Evident in Q1 improved profitability.
Radio licenses surrendered for non-viable stations
DowngradeRadio now operating at EBITDA -₹3 Cr (breakeven at best). Prior calls expected stabilization; instead, rationalization underway.
Employee cost rationalization across group
UpgradeConsolidated employee cost down to ₹99 Cr from ₹111 Cr YoY. Right-sizing cited; consistent cost discipline.
Newsprint cost headwind acknowledged vs prior calls
DowngradeNow explicitly flagged as peak, no hedge available, double whammy with weak rupee. Prior calls were more sanguine; now cautious.
The Q&A
Intense shareholder pressure on preferential share issuance pricing (₹24 vs ₹70 book value). Mehul Pathak and Ranga Prasad challenged dilution, moral hazard, and lack of alternatives. Management held firm on SEBI formula, but clearly on defensive. No other material pushback on operations.
Preferential share issuance rationale — Ranga Prasad
PartialHT Media + DCL debt-laden; HMVL cash surplus not available for both. Preferential faster, certain vs rights. SEBI formula applied; 30-50% debt retirement accretive to EPS.
Print EBITDA margin sustainability — Rohan Agarwal
AnsweredNewsprint peaked at $650-700/MT, should plateau. If stable, margins defensible. Q2 has higher newsprint; exact margins depend on ad mix and pricing achieved.
Newsprint hedging and circulation price actions — Rohan Agarwal
AnsweredNo forward market for newsprint, so no hedging possible. Cover price hikes difficult; Hindi papers already repriced. Volume actions preferred to maintain reach.
Print ad revenue growth drivers — Yash R.
AnsweredMajority pricing via yield improvement program. Commercial revenues held on volume. Government rates up 7 years (Nov 2025), cycling benefit in next 2 quarters.
Circulation revenue breakdown — Yash R.
AnsweredMostly pricing (₹1.5 Cr absolute change despite 14%). Mix shift between subscription/line copies, discounting. Steady-state copy levels maintained.
Other income sustainability — Rohan Agarwal
AnsweredTreasury gains on mutual funds (NAV-based, not MTM). Yield curve movement end-quarter helped. Volatile; cannot predict. Also realized profit on asset sales.
Debt consistency vs prior statements — Mehul Pathak
PartialDebt in HT Media for 3-4 years post-COVID in English Print/Radio. HMVL is cash-positive. Consolidated net cash ₹922 Cr masks this split. Debt in HTMedia needs retirement.
Standalone vs consolidated reporting transparency — Mahima
DodgedBoth companies publish separate financials. Prefer one con-call for efficiency. Shareholders can ask on either company.
Guidance
No specific revenue target; maintain Q1 performance
LowMgmt expressed 'very hopeful' but stated 'no forward guidance.' Depends on macro, newsprint commodity, pricing power.
Print EBITDA margin ~13% baseline if commodity/forex stable
MediumCan model on 13% assumption. But imponderables: if dollar hits 100 and newsprint ₹700, margin dilution evident.
Newsprint prices peaked; should plateau before decline
LowMgmt 'best estimate' given no forward market. Commodity call subject to error. Dollar also at lifetime high.
Risks the call surfaced
Commodity/forex exposure
HighNewsprint 25-40% of COGS at $650-700/MT (peak). Dollar at lifetime high. No forward market for newsprint; cannot hedge. Full pass-through to margins if prices don't reverse.
Digital business execution
MediumDigital segment -28% revenue, -₹3 Cr EBITDA (margin -12%). Portfolio being reset for 'sustainable, profitable offerings.' No turnaround timeline or specific milestones provided.
Shareholder sentiment / governance
MediumBoard approved preferential issue at ₹24/share vs ₹70 book value (66% discount). Shareholders (Ranga Prasad, Mehul Pathak) voted against, citing dilution and ethical concerns. Mgmt defended SEBI formula pricing but credibility dented.
Revenue growth sustainability
MediumPrint ad revenue +15% driven 'substantially' by yield/pricing. Government rates increased Nov 2025 after 7 years; commercial pricing via yield improvement. Risk: if macro slows or competitive pressure rises, pricing power erodes and volumes may compress.
Return on equity
MediumAnalyst (Mehul Pathak) calculated: if ₹6 EPS sustained × 4 quarters + book value ₹70 = ROE <10%. This is below cost of capital in India (~12%). Capital trapped in low-return business.
Management
Score 6/10. Clear on business strategy and costs; candid on headwinds (newsprint, forex, digital challenges). Evasive on ROE improvement timeline and capital allocation rationale. Defensive on preferential share pricing. Delivered on FY26 strategic actions (OTTplay exit, radio downsizing, cost cuts). Print ad growth +15% via pricing demonstrates execution on yield program. But digital still unprofitable, timelines vague.
1 · Q2 FY27
Higher newsprint prices vs Q1; margin test vs delivered 13% OPM
2 · H2 FY27
Preferential issue capital deployed for debt retirement; EPS accretive if executed
3 · FY27-28
Digital business stabilization or exit decision; currently unprofitable
No growth thesis articulated beyond cost discipline.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.