Record profit masks execution slips on capacity targets
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 7/10
Grade B
Hit PAT target (1,652 Cr) but overstated growth % (32.7% not 33%). Missed capacity additions in H1; reaffirmed FY27 target lacks credibility given track record. Mundra SPPA regulatory resolution timeline slipped (Aug-Sep → Dec).
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Strong Q2 profit (₹1,652 Cr, +33% YoY) driven by coal pricing and DSM gains, but execution risk on 2.5 GW FY27 capacity target (H1 <500 MW) and rising curtailment (11% Q2 vs 8.8% Q1) pressuring RE margins. Long-term story (rooftop, pumped hydro, distribution assets) intact but requires flawless execution and regulatory approvals on Mundra SPPA (now due Dec, was Aug–Sep). Kleros Singapore case adds legal overhang. Warrant watchful hold pending H2 guidance clarity.
₹19635.9 Cr
Revenue · +26.3% YoY₹1652 Cr
Reported PAT · +32.7% YoYFlat
Margins · vs guidance: CorroboratedDid the claims hold up?
Highest-ever quarterly profit after tax of INR1,652 crores
METDelivered Q2 PAT 1,652 Cr matches; verified as highest single quarter profit
33% YoY profit growth; revenues up 26% in quarter
OVERSTATEDPAT growth 32.7% YoY (not 33%); 26% refers to YoY, not QoQ growth (actual QoQ 3.1%)
EBITDA up 5% YoY; H1 EBITDA 8,494 Cr up 7% YoY
UnverifiedFigures stated without full-year reconciliation; plausible but unverified against full results
2.5 GW capacity addition target for FY27; expect to meet that
OVERSTATEDH1 added <500 MW; 2.5 GW full year at risk; reaffirmed but execution credibility questioned
Shirwata pumped hydro project: INR11,871 Cr capex (board-approved)
OVERSTATEDEarlier estimates ~INR8,000-9,000 Cr; 48% cost overrun acknowledged; still being financed 75% debt/25% equity
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
Capacity addition momentum
DowngradeH1 added <500 MW against implicit 1.25 GW half-year pace. Prior Q1 call guided '2.5–3 GW' with 9+ GW by FY27 end. Now reaffirmed 2.5 GW but with caveat 'expect to meet that'—credibility low.
Mundra SPPA timeline
DowngradeQ1 guided 'state approvals expected Aug–Sep 2026.' Q2 now says 'resolution before Dec 2026.' Also said billing already underway under SPPA—a positive, but regulatory closure slipped 3–4 months.
Curtailment severity
DowngradeQ1 curtailment 8.8%; Q2 jumped to 11%. Analyst called this 'among highest' in peer group. No mitigation plan offered; management hopes 'connectivity improves subsequent quarters' but deadline unclear.
Coal profit sustainability
NeutralCoal JV EBITDA +37% YoY (Q2). Management guided continued tailwinds 'next 2 qtrs' but cautioned 'governed by geopolitical conditions; very difficult to comprehend how things will change beyond.' Downside risk if global coal prices fall.
The Q&A
Analysts pressed hard on curtailment headwinds (Sumit Kishore: 11% 'among highest'), capex overruns (Satyadeep Jain: Shirwata cost jump INR8–9k → ₹11,871 Cr), and execution credibility (capacity targets H1 miss). Management defended with 'evacuation lines delayed' and 'projects now ready'—holding firm on FY27 2.5 GW but offered little evidence. Confidence visible on long-term (rooftop, hydro) but defensive on near-term (curtailment persists, capex creeping).
Non-recurring profit — Mohit Kumar, ICICI Securities
AnsweredNo. PAT growth based on excellent performance by all operating businesses.
Mundra SPPA resolution — Mohit Kumar, ICICI Securities
PartialSPPA signed with Gujarat, filed in CERC, reserved for order. In discussion with 4 other states; 2 very advanced. Expect conclusion before December. Billing already underway under SPPA; impact already in reports.
RE Genco run-rate EBITDA — Puneet, HSBC
PartialINR2,231 Cr YTD = INR4,500 Cr annualized. Many plants in last 3–6 months; full impact in subsequent quarter, 60–70% of Q1 expected. Missed targets H1–Q2 but projects ready; 2.5 GW for FY27 expected to meet.
Rooftop solar economics — Puneet, HSBC
DodgedSubsidy till March; new avatar beyond. Growing very fast in U.P., Odisha, Maharashtra, Rajasthan, now Delhi. Good state support enabling scale.
RE Genco curtailment forecast — Sumit Kishore, Axis Capital
PartialAbout 8.8% in Q1; 11% in Q2. Industry-wide issue; looking at connectivity pipeline. Hopefully eases in subsequent quarters. BESS instalment will help.
HVDC bidding strategy — Satyadeep Jain, Ambit Capital
AnsweredDid not bid HVDC. Examining OEM availability and technology partners; back-to-back arrangements needed; monitoring opportunities.
Shirwata pumped hydro capex — Satyadeep Jain, Ambit Capital
PartialConfusion on exact number; board-approved INR11,871 Cr. Two reservoirs, different timeline, settlement reservoir already exists. Conservative capex estimate on gross basis.
Coal JV profitability — Apoorva Bahadur, IIFL Capital
PartialCombination of efficiency and DSM. Subsidy present till March; new subsidy avatar beyond. Coal prices governed by geopolitical; difficult beyond next 5–6 months. But next 2 qtrs expect momentum to continue.
Singapore litigation timeline — Subhadip Mitra, Nuvama
AnsweredApproached enforcement and shares attached in TPIL and Bhira. Formally notified shareholders within 14 days. Shares pledged with consortium banks; they'll approach as well. Expect 3–6 month legal process; finality in Singapore Supreme Court by then.
PSP project commissioning timing — Subhadip Mitra, Nuvama
AnsweredBhivpuri operational H1 CY2029; Shirwata commissioned CY2031. Expect cash flows from both over multi-year period.
Cash deployment across renewables — Puneet, HSBC
AnsweredIn Q2 about INR10,000 Cr capex; roughly INR6,000 Cr to renewables. Rest across multiple businesses. Lying across hundreds of businesses and renewables; INR1,000–1,400 Cr capex needed; September close to INR1,400 Cr.
Guidance
FY27 capex ₹25,000 Cr (50% renewables), unchanged
HighReaffirmed in Q2 call. Shirwata pumped hydro ₹11,871 Cr (phased); solar ingot/wafer plant ₹500–600 Cr (est.). Renewable capex on track if capacity additions catch up.
Mundra SPPA resolution by December 2026; cash start H2
MediumSlipped from Aug–Sep (Q1 prior) to December. Billing already underway but revenue recognition dependent on tariff approval by CERC. 4 other states in advanced discussion but timeline unclear.
Coal JV profit tailwinds continue next 2 quarters; expect ₹400–odd Cr benefit
MediumDSM and coal price-driven. Management cautious: 'Very difficult to comprehend how things will change beyond [5–6 months].' Risk if global coal prices fall or geopolitical tensions ease.
RE Genco EBITDA: ₹4,500 Cr annualized run-rate on 7.1 GW; full impact H2 FY27
Medium11% curtailment Q2 (up from 8.8% Q1) is headwind. Expects connectivity improvements and BESS installations to ease. No reduction in EBITDA guidance but risk visible.
FY27 capacity adds 2.5 GW (reaffirmed); expect to meet target
LowH1 <500 MW added; evacuation line delays cited. 2.5 GW for full year implies ~2 GW in H2—aggressive catch-up. Credibility questioned by analyst pushback.
Shirwata 1,800 MW phased; first 1,000 MW board-approved at ₹11,871 Cr total capex
MediumCapex jumped 48% from ballpark ₹8–9k Cr. Two-reservoir project, phased execution. Downside risk if further contingencies emerge.
Ingot/wafer plant operational by March 2028; approvals received; work starts this month
MediumChina tech export controls risk. Management hedging: 'Will get more clarity end-November.' ALMM3 delays possible if import restrictions tighten.
Risks the call surfaced
RE Curtailment
High11% curtailment Q2 (vs 8.8% Q1, industry avg ~8–9%) erodes capacity utilization. At 7.1 GW, implies ₹200–250 Cr quarterly EBITDA loss vs full PLF. Structural grid congestion; evacuation line delays cited.
Capacity Addition Execution
HighH1 added <500 MW against 2.5 GW full-year target. Implies 2 GW catch-up in H2—aggressive given evacuation line delays. Credibility of reaffirmed guidance questioned by analysts.
Singapore Litigation (Kleros)
HighKleros enforcement appeal in Singapore Supreme Court hearing 19 Jan 2027. Claims on TPIL/Bhira shares (₹650M+ at stake). If ruled against, liability crystallizes. 3–6 month legal process expected. Reputational/capital allocation impact.
Regulatory Asset Appreciation & Tariff Risk
MediumDistribution regulatory assets jumped 28% YoY to ₹83.1B (Delhi, Odisha). Requires state commission tariff revisions to monetize. Delhi full quorum now in place but timeline for tariff closure uncertain. If delayed, cash flow deferred.
Mundra SPPA Regulatory Resolution
MediumSPPA signed with Gujarat; filed in CERC for order. 4 other states in discussion. Billing already underway but revenue recognition deferred until tariff approval. Timeline slipped Aug–Sep → December. If further delayed, FY27 cash impact.
Management
Score 7/10. Clear on strategy (renewables, rooftop, hydro, distribution assets) and transparent on challenges (curtailment, capex overruns, regulatory delays). Some ambiguity on 26% revenue growth claim (YoY vs QoQ could confuse). Financial disclosures detailed and segmentwise. NDA shields prevent disclosure of SPPA state identities, limiting investor clarity. Hit PAT target (₹1,652 Cr) but overstated growth % (32.7% vs claimed 33%). Missed capacity addition targets in H1 (<500 MW vs 1.25 GW pace); reaffirmed FY27 2.5 GW but credibility low. Mundra SPPA regulatory timeline slipped 3–4 months. Capex estimates undershot (Shirwata +48%). Mixed track record.
1 · Dec 2026
Mundra SPPA resolution by state DISCOMs; tariff billing to commence
2 · 19 Jan 2027
Singapore Supreme Court hearing on Kleros appeal (₹650M claim at stake)
3 · H2 FY27
Capacity commissioning acceleration: evacuation lines expected Dec–Jan; 1,800 MW pumped hydro FID (Shirwata Phase-2)
Warrant watchful hold pending H2 guidance clarity.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.