Order book soars 30%, but profit falls 42% YoY on inventory write-downs
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 6/10
Grade C
FY27 volume guidance 410k–430k reaffirmed (on track at ~200k H1); prior margin and EBITDA/ton range maintained but Q2 EBITDA/ton fell to ₹9,220 from ₹15,660 Q1—a material miss attributed to inventory valuation.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Strong order book recovery (₹2,200 Cr, +30%) and capacity expansion (Telangana) are structurally positive, but Q2 profit collapsed 41.8% YoY despite 9.6% revenue growth. Management blames notional inventory revaluation with promised Q3 reversal, but magnitude of decline and lack of quantified breakdowns erode trust. Demerger may unlock value but approval pending Jan–Feb 2027.
₹1269.8 Cr
Revenue · +9.6% YoY₹72.9 Cr
Reported PAT · −41.8% YoYCompressing
Margins · vs guidance: MixedDid the claims hold up?
Order book has increased significantly and contains high-margin orders
OVERSTATEDOrder book ₹2,200 Cr (+30% QoQ, up from ₹1,700 Cr), but NPM fell to 5.8% from 10% (Q1 implied), EBITDA/ton ₹9,220 vs ₹15,660 Q1
Inventory valuation impact is entirely notional and will reverse in Q3
PartialPAT down 41.8% YoY and 72.6% QoQ despite 9.6% revenue growth; inventory revaluation claimed as the culprit but no quantified impact disclosed
Company on track for FY27 volume guidance of 410k-430k tons
METH1 dispatches ~200k tons mentioned; management suggests additional 230k possible in H2, implying full-year potential of 430k, within guidance
Export market showing strength, particularly North America rig counts
PartialExport mix improved YoY due to increased rig counts in North America, but export revenue remained flat H1 vs H1 FY26
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
Order book +30% QoQ
Upgrade₹1,700 Cr (Q1) → ₹2,200 Cr (Q2). Mix shifted toward high-margin cylinder pipes (₹144 Cr order cited). Demand visible in upstream and export segments.
Volume pace maintained
Neutral~200k tons H1 FY27 vs ~207k H1 FY26 guidance of 410k–430k annual stays on track. No change to full-year outlook despite profit miss.
EBITDA per ton compression
Downgrade₹15,660 (Q1) → ₹9,220 (Q2), a 41% drop. Management pins to inventory write-down; prior-year guidance was ₹10–15k range, now subfloor in reported numbers.
Demerger timeline announced
New3-entity split progressing; Nagothane (0.5–20"), Mangaon (0.5–6"), Telangana (up to 14"). Stock exchange approval awaited by Jan–Feb 2027.
The Q&A
Moderate Q&A pressure on inventory revaluation and margin recovery. Saket Kapoor drilled on EBITDA/ton decline and timeline for reversal; Kaushal Bengani reiterated notional impact but declined to quantify. Analysts probed order book composition (high-margin %) and capex plans; management deflected on demerger rationale and treasury strategy. Some evasion on export forecast percentages and anti-dumping duty stance (matter under authority consideration).
Inventory valuation impact — Saket Kapoor, Kapoor & Co
PartialInventory buildup (₹500 Cr) due to rapid raw material price increases. Notional accounting hit per Ind AS. Once inventory converts to pipes and dispatches, impact reverses; better margins in next quarter expected.
Order book quality — Kirtan Mehta, Baroda BNP Paribas
PartialSlide 15 has breakdown. Execution timelines 2–4 months. No customer project details disclosed. High-margin orders (cylinder pipes, drill pipes) in mix.
Volume trajectory FY27 — Saket Kapoor, Kapoor & Co
AnsweredOn track for 430k guidance. First half ~200k, remaining 230k possible in H2. Order execution 2–4 months; order book is rolling 3–4 month horizon.
Demerger strategy — Saket Kapoor, Kapoor & Co
DodgedDetailed in SEBI submissions (public domain). Each entity specialized by size range; different customer profiles (Nagothane=oil&gas, Mangaon=cold-drawn, Telangana=cylinder). Scheme awaits Jan–Feb 2027 approval; no public guidance on non-compete or synergy ratios.
Capital deployment — Mohammed Farooq Umar, Pearl Capital
PartialNIFTY, Smallcap have not created wealth past 2 years; not unique to us. Cash increased YoY. Waiting for opportunities; oil & gas sector showing early signs. Function of sector capex cycle, not company-specific.
Export and rig count linkage — Vijay Kumar, Trustline India
AnsweredExport segment seeing rise in rig counts; more orders expected. Data center pipes unlikely (require high-temp, high-pressure). Export pipes for drilling, not transportation. No data center opportunity for seamless.
Anti-dumping duty outlook — Sunil Jain, Nirmal Bang
DodgedDuty decision still pending with authorities (Jan 2027). Will know more then. Subject to authority consideration; cannot comment publicly.
Telangana capex and commissioning — Sandip Bharat Solanki, Individual Investor
PartialCold-drawn pipes project complete; Telangana finishing line under implementation, activated FY27. Hot mill upgrade timeline provided only after Telangana completion. No tonnage guidance for ₹350 Cr projects yet.
Guidance
FY27 volume 410k–430k tons (vs FY26 420k baseline)
HighH1 volumes ~200k achieved. H2 target 230k tons; on pace. Reaffirmed with no change despite Q2 profit miss.
EBITDA/ton ₹10–15k range maintained (prior guidance)
MediumQ2 actual ₹9,220/ton (below range floor) blamed on notional inventory valuation. Management expects reversal Q3; no revised guidance issued.
Telangana finishing line activation FY27; adds 230k annual capacity
High₹107 Cr orders placed, ₹89 Cr paid. Cold-drawn project complete. Next capex (hot mill ₹350 Cr for ₹800–1,000 Cr revenue) pending Telangana completion.
Risks the call surfaced
Profitability deterioration
HighPAT fell 41.8% YoY despite 9.6% revenue growth; EBITDA/ton ₹9,220 (Q2) vs ₹15,660 (Q1). Inventory revaluation blamed, but no quantified impact disclosed; magnitude suggests structural cost inflation risk.
Demerger execution risk
Medium3-entity demerger pending stock exchange approval (Jan–Feb 2027). Scheme rationale (synergy breakup value, non-compete) not publicly detailed. Market cap fragmentation risk; small-cap threshold breach if any entity falls below index criteria.
Order book execution
MediumOrder book ₹2,200 Cr with 2–4 month execution window is rolling 3–4 month horizon. Order composition shows higher-margin products (cylinder pipes ₹144 Cr) but actual margin realization depends on inventory clearance and cost management. Missed EBITDA/ton guidance in Q2 suggests execution headwinds.
Commodity price sensitivity
MediumSteel billet prices increased rapidly in Q1; Q2 increase slower. Inventory buildup reflects hedging against future price spikes, but accounting treatment (Ind AS revaluation) flattens reported profitability. If prices stabilize or decline, inventory write-ups could reverse; if inflation persists, further margin pressure.
Anti-dumping duty outlook
LowDGTR recommended flat rate ₹268/ton anti-dumping duty; final decision pending Jan 2027. Duty extension or withdrawal will impact Indian competitiveness. Import competition from China (pre-duty) eroded margins; duty supports pricing.
Management
Score 6/10. Moderate clarity. Kaushal Bengani (DGM, IR & Finance) fielded most questions but deflected on demerger rationale, anti-dumping stance, and capital deployment specifics. Acknowledged inventory revaluation hit but declined to quantify. Transparent on order book growth and volume tracking. Mixed. Volume guidance 410k–430k on track (H1 ~200k); Telangana capex progressing (₹89 Cr paid of ₹107 Cr orders). Profitability target ₹10–15k EBITDA/ton missed badly in Q2 (₹9,220). Demerger scheme filed but timeline slipped to Jan–Feb 2027 approval.
1 · Q3 FY27 (Dec 2026)
Inventory revaluation reversal; management expects ₹310+ EBITDA/ton vs ₹9,220 Q2
2 · FY27 (ongoing)
Telangana finishing line activation; adds 230k annual capacity from base 200k
3 · Jan–Feb 2027
Demerger scheme approval from stock exchanges; 3-entity structure clears
Demerger may unlock value but approval pending Jan–Feb 2027.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.