Profitability breakthrough, but volume growth slowed
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 7/10
Grade B
Reaffirmed FY27 ₹840 Cr revenue target and quartz ₹180-200 Cr FY28 guidance; on track but execution friction emerging in Q2 volume growth and cash conversion.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Midwest achieved a key inflection point in Q2 with quartz becoming EBIT positive, underpinning long-term growth ambitions. However, delivered result shows deceleration: granite volume growth slowed to 7%, Q-o-Q revenue fell 4.8%, and H1 cash flow turned negative (₹20 Cr outflow) despite reported profitability—a red flag on working capital management. While FY27 guidance of ₹840 Cr appears on track and rare earth upside is real, near-term execution risks and margin compression from fuel costs limit upside.
₹182.5 Cr
Revenue · +15% YoY₹30.2 Cr
Reported PAT · +9.2% YoYCompressing
Margins · vs guidance: MixedDid the claims hold up?
H1 FY27 achieved 24% revenue growth, 18% PAT growth
OVERSTATEDQ2 FY27 delivered 15% YoY revenue growth, 9.2% PAT growth
Quartz volume Q2 around 16,000 tons, targeting 12,000-15,000 tons next quarter
METQuartz volumes reached 16,000 tons in Q2 as stated, margin contribution negative despite EBIT positive
Fuel cost increase 30-35% H1 vs prior year, fully passed to customers
METPricing power enabled cost absorption, realized prices increased ₹90-120 per unit
Granite volume growth H1 at 14%, Q2 slowdown to 7%
METQ2 volume 16,000 tons vs expected 15,000-20,000 tone range, slightly lower than guided
Quartz business achieved EBIT positive status in Q2
METInternally reported as milestone, though EBITDA contribution still negative at ₹1-2 Cr loss
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
Quartz volume guidance
MaintainedReaffirmed ₹100-120 Cr FY27 guidance; Q2 at ₹13.5 Cr annualized (~₹27 Cr run-rate), tracking toward upper bound. Phase 1 target ₹180-200 Cr FY28 unchanged.
Phase 2 capex timing
NeutralStill targeting end-FY27/Q2-FY28 commissioning for Phase 2 (606k MTPA expansion); HPQ integration added to scope. No timeline slip, but regulatory delays on rare earth permits pushing contingency.
Rare earth project scope
NewThree projects now in focus: Sri Lanka (beach sand mining), Indonesia (Perminas JV), Kerala (TAM sourcing via APMDC subsidiary). Magnet manufacturing PLAs under discussion; no timeline yet.
Fuel cost and pricing power
Maintained30-35% H1 fuel cost inflation fully absorbed via ₹90-120 per unit price increases and cost savings (EVs, renewables). No change in pricing strategy; pass-through remains effective.
Capex guidance
Maintained₹300 Cr planned for 3-4 years (Phase 2 ₹120 Cr, rare earth mineral separation ₹100 Cr, other expansion). No reduction; aggressive capex maintained.
The Q&A
Analysts pressed on volume growth slowing (Q2 7% vs expected 15,000-20,000 tons), quartz margins staying negative, and cash flow turning negative. Management held firm on H1 24% growth claim, blamed Q2 slowdown on seasonality/monsoon/weather, and attributed cash outflow to temporary working capital timing. CFO negative reception on the cash flow explanation; some skepticism on quartz profitability depth, but management defended timeline for Phase 2 and rare earth upside.
Quartz volume trajectory — Alok Deora, Motilal Oswal
AnsweredQ1 ~3,000-4,000 tons, Q2 16,000 tons, Q3 25,000-30,000 tons, Q4 35,000-40,000 tons. Goal is 12,000-15,000 ton monthly by Jan-Feb; will ramp 18,000 tons next year.
Quartz margin compression — Alok Deora, Motilal Oswal
PartialFixed costs in Q2 preventing EBITDA accretion; as capacity utilizes toward 12,000-15,000 tpa in Q4, EBITDA should improve. Positive PAT due to lower depreciation at this stage.
CFO negative drivers — Sanj Arya, Resurgence Fincap
AnsweredThree factors: extended credit terms to domestic market (INR20 Cr incremental receivables), inventory buildup for quartz and granite (INR14 Cr), and trade payables timing. Cash is sitting in receivables; near-term should normalize.
Rare earth extraction timeline — Sanj Arya, Resurgence Fincap
AnsweredSri Lanka: permits target this quarter, work starts next quarter. Indonesia: definitive agreement signing this quarter, work starts Q4/Q1. Kerala: waiting for government team formation; once KMML administrative structure finalized, we'll fast-track. All three in 12-18 month execution window.
Quartz demand and customer base — Chirag Gandhi, Astrali Investments
AnsweredDemand is robust domestically; bulk of 60,000-70,000 tpa capacity can be absorbed by single large customer (Triveni doubling capacity, Gold Plus in Bellary also doubling). Second customer (Gold Plus) already in talks. High-quality quartz is preferred by processors; local preference strong over mixing.
Phase 2 commissioning status — Chirag Gandhi, Astrali Investments
AnsweredPhase 2 building already started; machinery orders placed. Stabilization targeted for 9,000-10,000 tpa internally; Q4 partial process completion. First phase by Q2 next year; HPQ added in Q3/Q4 FY28, full facility available by end of FY28.
Rare earth pricing and supply dynamics — Rushabh Shah, RBSA Investment Manager
AnsweredChina produces 400k-500k tons magnet materials; rest of world only 20k tons. Magnet market growing 12-13% yearly. Premium pricing holds for non-China oxide production due to supply constraints; defense/aerospace applications willingly pay premium. As world doubles magnet production, our oxide pricing will stay elevated due to China supply restrictions on oxides exports.
Electric vehicle capex ROI — Rushabh Shah, RBSA Investment Manager
Answered10 trucks saving INR2 to INR2.5 Cr annually; group captive renewable (6 megawatts) saving INR4-5 Cr annually per unit power installed. Additional capex solar for granite and quartz planned; will provide baseline data before full fleet electrification rollout.
Quartz utilization and profitability path — Bala Murali Krishna, Oman Investment Advisors
AnsweredStarting from very low base (~3,000 tons Q1), ramping to 16,000 tons Q2. Targeting ramp to 12,000-15,000 monthly by year-end; full year we plan 15,000-18,000 ton monthly average run-rate. Once at 12,000-15,000 tpa, EBITDA will normalize and contribution to consolidated EBITDA will be positive.
Capex spend tracking and rare earth feasibility — Shreya, Individual Investor
PartialPhase 2: INR120 Cr planned (mostly spent on rare earth mineral separation for Sri Lanka project). Initial spend concentrated on rare earth vertical; Phase 2 follow-on quarterly. Rare earth projects are focus for next 12-18 months; viability depends on executing Sri Lanka (first revenue source) and Indonesia (2-3 quarters later). Both projects large-scale, decent-sized, and central to growth strategy.
Guidance
FY27 total ₹840 Cr (granite ₹720 Cr, quartz ₹100-120 Cr)
HighH1 tracking ~₹374 Cr at 24% growth; H2 needs ₹465 Cr (20%+ growth) to hit target. Seasonality headwinds in Q2 suggest Q3-Q4 uplift required.
Quartz Phase 1 ₹180-200 Cr FY28 (from current ₹100-120 Cr FY27)
MediumPhase 2 capex in progress; full facility by end-FY28 / early-FY29. Volume ramp from 16k tons Q2 to 15k-18k tpa sustained. Realization ₹9,500-₹12,000/ton.
Granite volume growth 10-12% FY27 (after 7% slowdown in Q2)
MediumH1 volume +14% YoY; Q2 7% QoQ suggests seasonal compression. Full-year tracking toward mid-double-digit growth; weather/monsoon impact cited.
EBITDA margin 26-27% FY27 (vs 25.5% delivered Q1)
MediumQ2 margin improvement dependent on quartz scaling and fuel cost absorption. Current 26.1% OPM aligns; EBITDA likely 26-27% range if quartz ramps as planned.
Quartz margins at optimal level (higher than traditional granite business) at full capacity
MediumQuartz currently EBIT positive but EBITDA negative (fixed-cost drag). At 12k-15k tpa sustained, margins should exceed granite's 26-27% EBITDA.
₹300 Cr capex over 3-4 years (Phase 2 ₹120 Cr, rare earth mineral separation ₹100 Cr, other)
MediumPhase 2 capex being deployed end-FY27 onwards. Rare earth projects pending regulatory approvals; capex timing flexible but magnitude firm.
Risks the call surfaced
Project execution risk
HighSri Lanka beach mining, Indonesia Perminas JV, and Kerala APMDC contingent on government team formation and administrative clearances. Delays of 2-4 quarters possible if KMML (Kerala) team formation stalls.
Volume and capacity utilization
MediumQuartz Phase 1 ramping from 3k-4k tons (Q1) to 16k tons (Q2) to 25k-30k tons (Q3) target. If ramp slows, EBITDA negative phase extends beyond Q4; fixed costs (₹1-2 Cr EBITDA drag noted) would persist longer.
Working capital and cash flow
HighH1 operating cash flow negative ₹20 Cr despite ₹30+ Cr PAT. WC cycle expanded from 104 days (FY26) to 127 days (H1 FY27). INR25 Cr incremental receivables (domestic credit extension) and INR14 Cr inventory buildup are drag factors.
Cost inflation and pricing power
MediumFuel costs surged 30-35% in H1 FY27. While pricing power absorbed most of this (₹90-120/unit increases, 6% higher realization in engineered stone), macro downturn could limit further pass-through, especially in granite (commodity-like product).
Market concentration
MediumTriveni is largest quartz customer, doubling capacity; absorbs majority of Midwest quartz supply. If Triveni's capex slows or slab demand softens, Midwest quartz volume target (60k-70k tpa Phase 2 capacity) could face absorption risk.
Management
Score 7/10. Transparent on volume trajectory and capex plans; candid on working capital issues. Somewhat defensive on fuel cost absorption and cash flow negativity, but provided reasonable explanations. NDA-shielded on specific rare earth project valuations and customer names for large accounts. Met H1 growth targets (24% revenue, 18% PAT claimed; Q2 showed 15% revenue, 9% PAT). Granite volume +14% H1 but decelerated to 7% QoQ. Quartz achieved EBIT positive milestone on schedule. Phase 2 capex tracking; rare earth projects moving toward execution but regulatory delays emerging.
1 · Q3 FY27
Sri Lanka rare earth project permitting complete, ground work to start; Indonesia Phase 1 definitive agreement signing
2 · Q4 FY27
Quartz Phase 2 plant commissioning begins; HPQ added to Phase 2 capex plan
3 · Q2 FY28
Quartz Phase 1 target ₹180-200 Cr annual run-rate; Phase 2 full operational capacity (12,000-15,000 tpa)
While FY27 guidance of ₹840 Cr appears on track and rare earth upside is real, near-term execution risks and margin compression from fuel costs limit upside.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.