Strong volume growth offset by margin compression; costs claimed peaked
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 6/10
Grade B
Hit FY27 volume target so far (10.5/20 expected HY1). Reaffirmed capex. But refuses UAE transparency and claims cost recovery without EBITDA projections.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Q1 shows strong volume growth (+15% YoY) but severe margin compression (PAT -17.5% despite revenue +18%). Management attributes this to temporary Middle East supply shocks (pet-coke→coal, gypsum shortage, clinker factor drop). Maintains FY27 guidance of 40 MT volumes and ₹1,500 Cr capex. Key risk: trade-sales mix collapse (62% vs 71%) and clinker factor deterioration (1.58→1.50) may be structural, not transient.
₹6233.1 Cr
Revenue · +18% YoY₹531.1 Cr
Reported PAT · −17.5% YoYCompressing
Margins · vs guidance: MixedDid the claims hold up?
Fuel cost peaked in Q1 at 1.95/kcal; expects stabilization Q2
MISSCost headwinds cited, but PAT fell 17.5% YoY despite 18% revenue growth; margin squeeze evident
Volume growth 15%+ YoY despite Middle East disruption
METConsolidated volumes 114.5 MT vs 99.6 MT prior year Q1 = +14.9% growth; standalone India 10.4-10.5 MT vs 9.1 MT = +14.3%; corroborated
Clinker factor drop and coal quality temporary, pet coke arriving now
OVERSTATEDClinker fell 1.58 to 1.50; trade sales fell 71% to 62%; no guarantee this reverses if coal sourcing remains poor
On track to deliver 40 MT FY27 volume guidance
METHY1 targeting 19.5-20 MT; at 52% of volume in H1 (industry norm 48%), implies H2 ~19-20 MT = ~40 MT full year; supported
RMC currently profit-neutral, targeting 5% EBITDA margin
OVERSTATEDRMC revenue ₹109 Cr Q1, but EBITDA not disclosed; no profitability evidence yet; overstated near-term contribution
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
Fuel cost 1.82 → 1.95/kcal
DowngradePet-coke 54%→9%, coal 32%→81% due to Middle East war. Fuel cost rose ₹0.13/kcal (7.1% increase). Claimed 'peaked' in Q1 but margin impact real.
Trade sales 71% → 62%
DowngradeForced non-trade shift due to clinker factor constraint (1.58→1.50). Lower margin product. Mgmt says temporary but no reversal mechanism clear yet.
Clinker factor 1.58 → 1.50
DowngradeHigh-ash coal reduced pozzolanic content, raised gypsum consumption. Limits blended cement, favors OPC (non-trade). Reversal depends on coal quality recovery.
Consolidated reporting adoption
NeutralShift from standalone to consolidated numbers; Q1 consolidated EBITDA ₹1,272 Cr vs ₹1,333 prior Q (EBITDA/ton ₹1,111 vs ₹1,339). Masks performance deterioration via consolidation.
Volume guidance 40 MT FY27
MaintainedPrior Q4 call: 40 MT. Current: 10.5 MT Q1, 9-9.5 MT Q2 target = ~20 MT H1, on track for 40 MT. No change.
The Q&A
Moderate pressure on transparency. Analysts pressed UAE metrics, subsidiary breakdown, RMC profitability; management deflected with 'consolidated focus' and refusal to disaggregate. Defensive on pricing outlook (won't forecast). Accepted cost headwind reality but framed as Q1-specific abnormality; some skepticism on reversal timing.
Fuel cost & realization — Rajesh Ravi, HDFC Securities
AnsweredFuel 1.95/kcal. Clinker 1.50 vs 1.58 prior. Trade 62% vs 71%. Realization ₹4,919/MT (standalone) vs ₹4,854.
Q2 fuel cost outlook — Rajesh Ravi, HDFC Securities
PartialFuel almost peaked; may go up ₹0.02-0.03/kcal only. Pet-coke contracted supplies now arriving. Expects no material increase if Middle East calm.
Non-trade shift cause — Amit Murarka, Axis Capital
AnsweredCoal quality (20% ash) forced clinker ratio down 1.58→1.50. High-ash clinker limits pozzolanic dilution, requires more gypsum (expensive). Result: must sell more OPC to non-trade. Gypsum does not affect trade vs non-trade; only raw-material cost.
Trade-non-trade reversion — Amit Murarka, Axis Capital
PartialTarget 70% trade, 30% non-trade historically. But no timeline given; depends on clinker factor recovery.
Regional volume growth — Kunal Shah, DAM Capital
AnsweredNorth 66% util, +20% growth. East 60% util, flat (coal quality constraint). South 57% util, +54% growth (11→16.9 MT due to new plant + West India penetration). Overall 62%.
East market flat demand — Kunal Shah, DAM Capital
AnsweredEast is flat for Shree due to own coal quality & clinker factor constraint (1.50 vs Nuvoco's 1.7). East is trade market where higher conversion helps. Not market; own constraint.
Q2 cost recovery — Pinakin, HSBC
PartialWe anticipate so but never give EBITDA projections. As of July 31, sold 3.1 MT this month, demand okay, fuel not increased. If Middle East calm, expect better profitability. Why wait H2, look at Q2 only.
Trade sales normalization — Pinakin, HSBC
DodgedHopefully, yes.
UAE EBITDA per ton — Siddharth, Kotak Securities
DodgedI will not disclose. Look at consolidated grey cement business EBITDA and volumes; figure it out yourself. Not going into specific number game.
Freight cost trend — Siddharth, Kotak Securities
AnsweredWhere is the lower cost? You do your math again. It's not lower.
UAE EBITDA this quarter — Rahul Gupta, Morgan Stanley
DodgedI'm not going to share it.
FY27 volume guidance — Jashandeep Chadha, Nomura
AnsweredEast +20% incremental, South +penetration to West India. Industry 7-8% growth, Shree targeting 10%. Did 35.4 MT last year, guiding 40 MT FY27.
Capex & Northeast economics — Jashandeep Chadha, Nomura
AnsweredFY27 capex ₹1,500 Cr maintained (₹456 Cr in Q1). Northeast 1 MT test at Q4 FY28; infrastructure for 4-5 MT total. ₹1,800 Cr per MT capex because learning steps; duopoly (Star, Dalmia). Not buying $5 EBITDA at $110.
Realization gap closure — Jashandeep Chadha, Nomura
PartialNo improvement Q1; was fighting on cost & production front, not ideal quarter. Should be on track to catch up delta going forward.
Cost levers & ECVs — Ritesh Shah, Investec
AnsweredElectric commercial vehicles (ECVs) being piloted; 100 units targeted FY27. 40L diesel vehicle costs ₹1Cr; ECV ₹2.5 Cr but fuel cost 1/10th. Renewable energy 61%→66%. Rail 9% volumes. All cost-focused.
BESS implementation — Ritesh Shah, Investec
AnsweredIdentified few sites, small pilot underway. If succeeds, will scale. BESS 85% efficiency (15% loss); must load cost analysis with 85% availability. Theoretical now; testing viability before multiply.
Clinker factor aspiration — Ritesh Shah, Investec
PartialQ1 clinker 1.50 vs 1.58 prior. (No year-out target stated explicitly.)
Northeast approvals & timeline — Satyadeep Jain, Ambit Capital
AnsweredAs of this morning (July 31) 8:30 meeting, all approvals in place. Media reports can be dismissed. Only Guinness Book World Record holder of brownfield plant commissioning in 14 months.
RMC revenue Q1 — Navin Sahadeo, ICICI Securities
AnsweredRMC revenue ₹109 Cr Q1, ₹90 Cr March'26, ₹40 Cr June'25.
Capex FY28 guidance — Rajesh Ravi, HDFC Securities
PartialNot at the moment. Give one more quarter, will get back in next call.
Lead distance & cash — Harsh Mittal, Emkay Global
AnsweredLead distance 459→445. Consolidated net cash June'25 ₹7,733 Cr → June'26 ₹8,348 Cr.
M&A plans — Harsh Mittal, Emkay Global
AnsweredNo. Don't have heart to buy $5 EBITDA at $110 capex then admit wrong decision. 40-year history; know the business.
Pricing outlook — Girija Ray, Nirmal Bang
DodgedNever take a call on selling price in 40-year career. Market-related. Don't want to take investors up garden path. Give cost guidance if external env same; price, no call.
Consol capex guidance — Prateek Kumar, Jefferies
Partial₹1,500 Cr is India-only. UAE expansion funded from UAE ops, no remittance. Don't have consolidated capex number today; will share after returning to Kolkata by 4-5 Aug.
Guidance
FY27: 40 million tons volume (maintained)
HighGuided Q4 FY26, maintaining on call. Q1 10.5 MT + Q2 9-9.5 MT target = 19.5-20 MT H1, on track.
Cost headwinds peaked Q1; stabilization expected Q2 onwards
MediumFuel cost 1.95/kcal claimed peak; pet-coke arriving; gypsum cost expected to normalize. But no specific margin % target given; 'almost peaked' is hedge.
Trade sales reversion to 70%+ expected; upside to EBITDA as mix normalizes
LowClinker factor recovery (1.50→1.55+) contingent on coal quality improvement. No guarantee timeline.
FY27 capex ₹1,500 Cr (India-only; excl. UAE self-funded)
HighQ1 spent ₹456 Cr. FY27 focused on RMC, logistics, Meghalaya infrastructure. UAE doubling funded from UAE cash.
Northeast plant: 1 MT initial, 4-5 MT infrastructure by Q4 FY28
MediumLearning curve model; approvals confirmed; duopoly market (Star, Dalmia); ₹1,800 Cr/MT capex intensity; subsequent expansion cheaper.
Risks the call surfaced
Fuel & raw material volatility
HighPet-coke cut 54%→9%; forced coal shift to 20% ash content. Fuel cost spiked 1.82→1.95/kcal (+7.1%). Management claims reversal but no certainty if war escalates.
Product mix deterioration
MediumClinker factor 1.58→1.50 due to high-ash coal chemical interaction; forces OPC-heavy production; trade sales fell 71%→62% (lost premium segment).
Margin compression
HighPAT fell 17.5% YoY despite 18% revenue growth; fuel +7.1%, non-trade mix loss (lower margin), gypsum cost elevated. Realization +₹65/MT insufficient.
East market execution risk
MediumEast utilization 60%, flat YoY growth (vs 20% North, +54% South). Coal quality constraint limits conversion factor to 1.50 vs Nuvoco 1.7. Structural underperformance vs peer.
RMC capital sink
MediumRMC revenue ₹109 Cr Q1 but acknowledged as profit-neutral. 26 operational (19 start of year + 8 added Q1), +10 planned Q2. Capital being deployed with minimal EBITDA contribution.
Northeast plant viability
MediumNE plant 1 MT initial, infrastructure for 4-5 MT. Duopoly (Star, Dalmia) = pricing discipline risk. ₹1,800 Cr/MT capex intensity high; scaling contingent on market acceptance.
Management
Score 6/10. Defensive on subsidiary/UAE disclosures ('number game', 'not disclosing'); candid on cost headwinds and Q1 difficulty. Refuses EBITDA projections citing market risk. Repetitive on cost-peak narrative. Met Q1 volume targets (10.5 MT of 40 MT guide = on pace). Capex ₹456 Cr of ₹1,500 Cr = on track. RMC added 8 plants as stated. Prior guidance on 40 MT reaffirmed. Cost peak claim not yet evidenced (PAT -17.5%).
1 · Q2 FY27
Pet coke deliveries resume, gypsum costs normalize, clinker factor recovery
2 · Q3 FY27
UAE capacity doubling (7 MT) comes online post-war normalization
3 · Q4 FY28
Northeast/Meghalaya plant (1 MT initial) commissioned; 4-5 MT infrastructure built
Key risk: trade-sales mix collapse (62% vs 71%) and clinker factor deterioration (1.58→1.50) may be structural, not transient.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.