VAP momentum strong, but PAT down 39.5%—margin inflection uncertain
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 6/10
Grade B
Revenue guidance (VAP-driven growth, 19% YoY) hit. EBITDA margin (5.6%, high single-digit) delivered. PAT guidance implied but not met—major miss.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Heritage delivered 19% revenue growth and expanded VAP to 35% of mix, proving strategy. But profit crashed -39.5% YoY despite that lift—a red flag. EBITDA margin stuck at 5.6%, capped by 11% milk-cost inflation that management expects to persist into Q3 and beyond.
₹1319.6 Cr
Revenue · +18.6% YoY₹30.9 Cr
Reported PAT · −39.5% YoYCompressing
Margins · vs guidance: MixedDid the claims hold up?
Revenue grew 19% YoY, sustained despite inflationary environment
OVERSTATEDRevenue 1319.6 Cr, YoY growth 18.6%—slightly below claim, still robust
EBITDA margin stood at 5.6%, improved 98 bps sequentially from Q1
METEBITDA margin exactly 5.6%, delivered as stated
VAP contribution increased to 35.4% of revenue in Q2 (31.3% YoY)
METVAP (ex-ghee/butter) grew 32% YoY to INR4,510 Cr, 35.4% of revenue. Verified.
Profit after tax INR309 million, though elevated procurement costs weigh on profitability
MISSPAT 30.9 Cr, but YoY decline -39.5% masks revenue growth—earnings quality deteriorated
8% price increase taken across products to offset procurement inflation
METMilk 6%, VAP 9-10%. Weighted NR increase ~8%. September prices higher, Q3 impact accruing.
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
VAP contribution up 400 bps
UpgradeQ2 VAP 35.4% vs 31.3% YoY. Broad-based: lassi +89% vol, buttermilk +56%, ice cream +44%. Management executing mix-shift strategy on track.
Milk procurement cost accelerating
DowngradeINR47.73/L, +11% YoY vs Q1's ~7-8% estimate. Q3 expected +2.4-2.5% QoQ; no relief visible near-term. Management deflecting on normalization.
PAT trajectory deteriorated
DowngradeQ2 PAT 30.9 Cr, -39.5% YoY despite 19% revenue growth. Prior call implied profitability resilience; capex depreciation and operating leverage gaps exposed.
Margin expansion guidance hedged
WithdrawnAnalyst asked if 7%+ margin feasible in next 2-4 qtrs; CEO said 'hoping for better if milk prices come down' but no commitment. Signals inflection delayed.
The Q&A
Analysts pressed hard on milk costs (Sameer Gupta, Dradyumna Choudhary), competitive entry (Sidharth Jain), margin feasibility (Dhwanil Desai), and procurement adequacy (Sidharth Negandhi). Management held its line on VAP strategy and pricing power but was visibly defensive on PAT and cautious on milk-cost outlook—'wait and watch' tone on inflation normalization.
Milk cost moderation — Sameer Gupta, IIFL Capital
PartialPrices rose in Q2 despite previous hike last year. Field efforts improved volume 7% YoY. Performance uneven across country due to El Niño impact and regional supply constraints.
VAP growth drivers — Sameer Gupta, IIFL Capital
AnsweredGrowth is broad-based—lassi +89%, buttermilk +56%, ice cream +44%. Weather helped Q1; Q2 growth reflects expanded consumer franchise, sustained steady growth, not event-led.
Price hike timing — Vijay Jangir, Systematix
AnsweredOverall 8% NR increase (milk 6%, VAP 9-10%). Hikes taken in Jul, Aug, Sep; Sep prices much higher than Q2. Q3 benefit accruing. Q-o-Q Q3 milk prices up ~2.4-2.5% so far.
Cooperative pricing dynamics — Nirnam, Unique PMS
AnsweredAavin raised from INR38→INR41→INR43-44 recently. Passed through to Bangalore City immediately; staggered elsewhere on region/market basis. Benefit visible in sales upside.
Milk price cycle exit — Nirnam, Unique PMS
AnsweredConsumer prices don't come down once up; rarely see decline. VAP contribution expanding helps offset. 11% milk cost increase, but broader portfolio (VAP + ghee) masks via mix and pricing.
Cow milk procurement composition — Ishani, NV Alpha
AnsweredVolume.
VAP pricing vs volume growth trade-off — Sidharth Jain, YES Securities
AnsweredWeighted averages vary by region and pack type. Home packs lower margin but growing. Price timing: significant hikes in ghee, paneer, curd (90%+ of portfolio). Premium paneer Nourish+ up 15%. Timing staggered, but all seeing inflation pass-through.
Competitive entry and market size — Sidharth Jain, YES Securities
AnsweredDairy industry INR75k-80k Cr total; organized ~5k Cr (~6% penetration). Heritage ~5k Cr (0.5% penetration). Large competitor entry helps organize category. Gap is humongous. Heritage deeply focused on curd & fresh categories (leadership in curd, buttermilk) and ghee—all highly profitable, not commoditized.
Q3 milk procurement cost trajectory — Dradyumna Choudhary, Bow Head Investments
PartialQ-o-Q milk prices up ~2.4-2.5%. Expecting buffalo flush post-Diwali to ease supply; hoping for cooling effect but no speculation. Farmers shifting to cow milk cheaper alternative, but supply still tight.
Feed cost inflation trends — Dradyumna Choudhary, Bow Head Investments
PartialSupply-demand gap real. 8+ quarters of milk price increase unusual. Farmers shifting to cow milk to lower cost. Ideal situation: improved milk arrivals should ease feed & price pressure, but timing unclear.
VAP segment revenue breakdown — Rochwin Correia, KRIIS PMS
AnsweredCurd ~INR320 Cr annualized. Paneer ~INR200+ Cr (premium Nourish+ contributing 16-17% vol). Ice cream ~INR200 per liter revenue, close to INR350 Cr annualized basis.
Margin expansion path to 7%+ — Dhwanil Desai, Turtle Capital
PartialMoved from 4.6% (Q1) to 5.6% (Q2). Effort is to keep growing & absorb costs. Cost heads down as % of revenue except raw material (up as % revenue). Operating leverage improving. If milk prices come down, better off; if they stay, steady-state is current level.
Milk procurement CAGR adequacy — Sidharth Negandhi, CWC
PartialFocus on going deeper, not wider. Ice cream factory vision: INR500 Cr revenue in 6-7 years (vs INR110 Cr last year, ~INR200 Cr now). Milk procurement growth 6% long-term; sustainable with operational leverage & VAP mix.
Geographic expansion strategy — Sidharth Negandhi, CWC
AnsweredEntered 12 countries (Middle East, West Asia); domestic strategy is deeper not wider. Brands spreading geographically; household penetration improving where we operate. Global revenue ~0.5% of total but growing over time.
Guidance
VAP-driven growth to sustain revenue expansion
HighVAP now 35% of mix, growing 32% YoY. Management committed to expanding VAP contribution through new SKUs (Nourish+), portfolio premiumization.
High single-digit EBITDA target sustained
MediumAchieved 5.6% in Q2. Further expansion contingent on milk cost normalization. Management signaled 7%+ margin as aspiration but no commitment; 'hoping' for relief post-Diwali.
INR250 Cr capex planned for FY27 (from prior call)
LowNo update on this call. Large capex capitalized at FY-start is impacting depreciation and PAT. Expect continued investment in ice cream, procurement network expansion.
Risks the call surfaced
Milk cost inflation
HighMilk procurement costs up 11% YoY to INR47.73/L; Q3 expected +2.4-2.5% QoQ. Management calls this 'wait and watch' with hope for buffalo flush post-Diwali. But fundamental supply gap (high feed costs, climate stress, farmer income pressures) likely persistent.
Earnings quality deterioration
HighPAT down 39.5% YoY despite 19% revenue growth. EBITDA margin stuck at 5.6% (low industry tier). Capex depreciation impacting P&L more than EBITDA. Operating leverage weak due to raw material cost inflation dominating volume gains.
Competitive entry & market share
MediumLarge conglomerates entering dairy with scale, low-price strategy. Organized dairy market only ~6% of INR75k-80k Cr total. Heritage is 0.5% penetration; significant upside but also fierce competition. Differentiation via VAP & curd/buttermilk leadership is temporary moat.
Procurement network adequacy
MediumMilk procurement CAGR 6% long-term; revenue target mid-teens growth. Analyst questioned if this is sufficient. Management deflected, saying focus is going 'deeper' via VAP, but procurement bottle-neck risk exists if milk supply cannot scale.
Regulatory/commodity risk
MediumNandini (Karnataka) announced INR8/L price increase, implementation Nov 1. Aavin raised prices multiple times. Government-backed cooperatives can force pricing dynamics & cap Heritage's pricing power. Feed inflation (47% YoY) also structural.
Management
Score 7/10. Transparent on cost challenges, supply dynamics, competitive landscape. Candid on PAT depreciation drag, milk-cost persistence, and 'wait-and-watch' posture on inflation normalization. Some deflection on cooperative dynamics and forward margin guidance. Delivered on VAP strategy (32% growth, 35% of mix). Pricing actions (8% NR) taken timely. Revenue growth 19% YoY (misses 19% claim by 30 bps but close). Met EBITDA target (5.6%). PAT collapsed -39.5%—execution on profitability weak; attributed to capex depreciation rather than operational miss.
1 · Q3 FY27 (Oct–Dec)
Price hikes taken in Sep now accruing; VAP momentum continues (already +4.1% in first 15 days)
2 · Post-Diwali (Nov)
Buffalo milk flush expected to ease procurement inflation; management 'hoping' for moderation
3 · Q3–Q4 FY27
Feed cost deflation lag could ease operational expenses if cattle feed inflation moderates
EBITDA margin stuck at 5.6%, capped by 11% milk-cost inflation that management expects to persist into Q3 and beyond.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.