Strong volume growth, margin squeeze: cost headwinds outpacing pricing
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 6/10
Grade C
Prior FY27 guidance of 22.5-23 MT maintained, but PAT delivery weak vs revenue; cost pass-through falling short.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Strong volume momentum (+19% H1) and long-term capacity expansion (40 MTPA FY28 target) underway, but near-term margin pressure is acute: PAT grew only 6.3% despite 23.7% revenue growth, with QoQ PAT down 38.4% due to unabsorbed coal/fuel inflation. Pricing power limited; INR10-15 per ton still needed to cover cost headwinds.
₹3733.4 Cr
Revenue · +23.7% YoY₹169.3 Cr
Reported PAT · +6.3% YoYCompressing
Margins · vs guidance: OverstatedDid the claims hold up?
Volume growth 19% in H1; aiming for 24 MT full year
OVERSTATEDRevenue +23.7% YoY but PAT +6.3% YoY; Q2 EBITDA INR500 Cr down from INR639 Cr QoQ (-22%)
Cost increase peaked in Q2 at INR1.71 per Kcal; expecting partial benefit in Q3
MISSPAT collapsed 38.4% QoQ despite stable volumes; cost absorption evident
Paint business breakeven or positive EBITDA by FY27 end
PartialQ2 paint loss INR2 Cr; revenue INR116 Cr in Q2; targeting INR100 Cr more by Q4 but losses persist
Capacity commissioning on track for Jasalmer, Bathinda, Mahan by H1 FY28-FY29
PartialMahan coal block approval pending; Bathinda formal letters expected shortly; Jasalmer timelines conditional
Maintaining top 3-4 EBITDA per ton among peers despite cost pressures
UnverifiedManagement declined to provide per-ton EBITDA; consolidated reporting obscures segment-level margins
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
Volume guidance reaffirmed, not raised
NeutralFY27 target remained 22.5-23 MT (Q1 guidance); no upside surprise. Management hopeful for 24 MT but non-committal.
Cost inflation outlook extended to Q4
DowngradeQ1 call noted INR150/ton Q2 impact; now expecting INR80-100/ton in Q3-Q4 as well. Cumulative full-year impact larger than initially flagged.
Paint business timeline pressure
DowngradeExpected breakeven delayed; H1 loss INR2 Cr suggests margin recovery slower than prior optimism. INR100+ Cr Q4 revenue still insufficient to offset H1-H3 losses.
Capacity expansion on track but Mahan delayed
NeutralJasalmer/Bathinda H1 FY28 still on schedule; Mahan coal block first-half FY29 (pushing 12 months vs prior tease).
The Q&A
Moderate analyst pushback on margin vs peers and paint business profitability. Management held firm on volume targets and defended premium product strategy, citing market share gains in Central India expansion. Evasive on segment-level EBITDA disclosure.
Volume outlook H2 — Navin Sahadeo, ICICI Securities
AnsweredAlready mostly sold out in Maharashtra/Karnataka; only ~15% of total volumes exposed. Confident on annual guidance of 23 MT, could be closer to 24 MT.
Cost outlook impact — Navin Sahadeo, ICICI Securities
AnsweredPartial inventory benefit Q3, full impact Q4. Cost may reach INR2 if rates persist. INR10-15 more pricing needed to offset full impact.
Capex and debt peak — Sanjeev Singh, Motilal Oswal
AnsweredGross debt INR6,255 Cr, net debt could peak at INR6,000 Cr by end FY27. Greenfield expansions (Mudmapur, Panna 5-6 MT each) will have lower cost than Jaisalmer.
Paint business profitability — Philip Matthias, Geojit Investments
PartialQ2 revenue INR116 Cr, maintaining FY27 guidance; already reached INR250 Cr in H1. Expect INR100+ Cr more to reach target.
RMC margins — Prateek Kumar, Jefferies India
AnsweredRMC developing stage, no EBITDA now. 23 plants operational, targeting 50 by March 27. Takes 3-4 months post-commissioning to reach breakeven.
White cement growth — Harsh Mittal, Emkay Global
PartialCost increases haven't been fully absorbed; white cement pricing increased but margin pressure remains. Further price hikes challenging without customer pushback.
Mahan coal block timeline — Ritesh Shah, Investec Capital
AnsweredMahan work started; approvals received. Targeting first-half FY29 operationalization. Coal cost expected INR1-1.25 per ton.
Pricing power post-Diwali — Pinakin Parekh, HSBC
PartialStill require INR10-15 more. Packing costs high but not yet peaked. Rupee depreciation offers some offset. Price increases possible post-Diwali if market allows.
FY28 EBITDA margin guidance — Shravan Shah, Dolat Capital
Dodged700 Cr is 5% EBITDA; targeting 3-5% paint EBITDA. Paint margins improving gradually as volume scales.
Guidance
FY27: 23 MT cement volume (could reach 24 MT)
MediumQ1 stated 22.5-23 MT; now confident of 23 MT baseline, 24 MT upside if no disruptions (elections, Diwali)
FY27: Paint INR500-550 Cr revenue
MediumH1 achieved INR250 Cr; targeting INR100+ Cr Q4 to reach upper half; implies Q2-Q3 combined INR100 Cr
FY28: 40 MT total cement capacity (+ new expansions)
MediumJasalmer, Bathinda H1 FY28; 11 MTPA greenfield (Mudmapur+Panna); Mahan delayed to FY29
FY28: Paint EBITDA margin 3-5%
LowQ2 was loss; paint is at scale-up. Management targets 35-38% eventually but timeline unclear
Near-term: INR10-15 price hikes needed to offset cost inflation
MediumINR20 price increase mid-Sep post-Diwali expected; but ceiling exists due to competitive dynamics
RMC: Positive EBITDA once scaled; targeting breakeven by March 27 for majority of 50 plants
LowCurrently at loss; requires volume ramp and cost absorption; timeline optimistic
FY27-29: INR2,500 Cr capex yearly for expansion
HighConfirmed by CFO; covers Jasalmer, Bathinda, Mahan, paint, wall putty, RMC infrastructure
Risks the call surfaced
Input cost inflation
HighCoal, petcoke, diesel costs surged; INR80-100 per ton headwind in Q3-Q4. Pricing power limited by competition.
Margin compression
HighPAT +6.3% YoY vs revenue +23.7%; QoQ PAT down 38.4%. Cost inflation absorbed into margins; pricing lags.
New business execution risk
MediumPaint segment loss INR2 Cr Q2; RMC at 23 plants with 6-month breakeven lag per plant. Profitability timeline at risk.
Capacity expansion execution
MediumJasalmer/Bathinda aiming H1 FY28 but formal approvals (CTE/EC) for Bathinda still pending; Mahan coal block delayed to H1 FY29.
Demand volatility
LowMaharashtra/Karnataka drought; UP elections could disrupt construction. But only 15% of volumes exposed; management downplaying risk.
Management
Score 6/10. Clear on volume/capacity targets; opaque on segment-level profitability. Evasive on grey vs white EBITDA per ton despite direct questions. Forward-looking statements subject to caveat. Met FY27 guidance of 22.5-23 MT on track; paint business tracking INR500-550 Cr; Jasalmer/Bathinda H1 FY28 still on schedule. But paint losses and RMC ramp-up slower than initial optimism.
1 · Oct-Nov 2026
Price realization in Q3 post-Diwali; INR20/bag increase expected to sustain
2 · H1 FY28
Jasalmer (1 MTPA), Bathinda capacity commissioning; EC/CTE approvals imminent
3 · H1 FY28
Paint business margins inflect to positive EBITDA; targeting 35-38% eventual margin
Pricing power limited; INR10-15 per ton still needed to cover cost headwinds.
JK Cement Q2: consol PAT +6% YoY, margin slips to 13.6% despite 24% revenue growth
PAT +6.31% YoY · revenue +23.65% · margins compressing · miss vs street
₹3,733.42 Cr
+23.65% YoY
₹169.3 Cr
+6.31% YoY
4.49%
-0.7pp YoY
₹22.39
J.K. Cement's consolidated Q2 FY27 (quarter ended September 30, 2026) revenue came in at ₹3,733.42 Cr, up 23.6% YoY but down 7.4% sequentially from Q1's ₹4,031.72 Cr — below the ₹4,100-4,200 Cr band our pre-result preview flagged as the Street's expectation. Consolidated PAT was ₹169.30 Cr (owners' share ₹172.99 Cr after a ₹3.69 Cr non-controlling-interest loss), up a modest 6.3% YoY against 23.6% revenue growth, and down 38.3% from Q1's ₹274.62 Cr. EPS was ₹22.39 versus ₹35.91 in Q1 and ₹20.78 a year ago. No exceptional items featured in either the current or comparative quarters, so these are clean, reported-basis comparisons.
Q2 FY-2027 vs prior quarters
The gap between revenue and profit growth sits entirely in margins: operating margin (PBIDT excluding other income, on revenue) fell to roughly 13.6%, down from 16.1% in Q1 FY27 and 14.8% a year ago, while net profit margin slipped to 4.5% from 6.75% (Q1) and 5.19% (Q2 FY26). That lands well below the 17-18% EBITDA margin band the Street was pricing in pre-result — a miss on both revenue and margin. It also runs counter to management's own July guidance, when the company flagged a roughly ₹150/ton fuel-and-diesel cost increase for Q2 but called it a likely "peak" — the margin slippage recorded here, both sequentially and YoY, suggests that peak has not yet translated into relief; whether costs stabilize is now a call for the H2 FY27 numbers. Volume figures were not disclosed in this filing, so progress against management's FY27 target of 22.5-23 million tonnes cannot be directly verified from the results statement alone.
The stock went into the print at ₹4,880, down 4.7% over the past month of trading.
JK Cement expects a good double-digit growth in volumes for the full fiscal year, targeting around 22.5 to 23 million tons, driven by new capacity in Central India. While costs are expected to increase by approximately INR150 per ton in Q2 due to fuel and diesel prices, management anticipates this to be a peak cost. Th
— This quarter: missed
On a standalone (India cement) basis, PAT was ₹190 Cr on revenue of ₹3,594.70 Cr with EPS of ₹24.59 — comfortably above the consolidated PAT, underscoring that the overseas operations and newer businesses are a drag relative to the core India franchise this quarter. Alongside the results, the board appointed Price Waterhouse Chartered Accountants LLP as statutory auditor for a five-year term from FY28, succeeding S.R. Batliboi & Co., and approved a ₹130 Cr capex for JK Maxx Paints to add a 75,000 KLPA water-based paint plant in Telangana — within the already-sanctioned ₹600 Cr paints investment — as the Bhiwadi facility (currently 60% utilised) approaches full capacity by FY28. No management press release or concall commentary accompanied this filing to corroborate management's own framing of the quarter; the figures above are drawn solely from the regulatory financial-results statement.
W1
Whether the ~₹150/ton fuel-cost increase management called a likely Q2 "peak" recedes in H2 FY27 — OPM needs to recover from 13.6% toward the 17-18% band the Street expects.
W2
Progress toward FY27 volume guidance of 22.5-23 million tonnes (double-digit growth) as new Central India capacity ramps — not disclosed in this filing.
W3
Paints business trajectory toward the FY27 revenue target of ₹500-550 Cr and FY28 EBITDA breakeven, as the new Telangana plant adds capacity.
Volume Ramp vs. Margin Squeeze — Q2 Tests Cost Durability
After Q1's sharp margin compression, Q2 is a verdict on whether input-cost pressure is tactical or structural. Volume growth expected to continue, but the real story is EBITDA margin trajectory.
The Q2 Setup
Q1 FY27 delivered the paradox: revenue +20% YoY to ₹4,031.72 Cr, but consolidated PAT fell 15% to ₹274.62 Cr. EBITDA margin cratered 444 basis points to 16.07% (from 20.51% in Q1 FY26), crushed by fuel and maintenance cost inflation that outpaced the price hikes JK Cement could pass through. Q2 is a test: was that margin cliff a one-time shock from cost timing, or is it structural?
~₹4,100–4,200 Cr
Q1 base ₹4,031.72 Cr; sector volume growth ~8.5% expected; seasonal uplift from delayed monsoon
~17–18%
Q1 was 16.9%; watch if fuel/coal cost pass-through holds pricing or compresses further
~8–10%
Sector guidance; JK Cement targeting 22.5–23 MTPA for full FY27 (25 MTPA capacity now live)
FII 16.86% / DII 23.73%
Down from FII 18.58% a year ago; domestic accumulation ongoing
Strong Print vs. Weak Print
Strong Q2: Revenue +18–21% YoY, EBITDA margin stabilizes at 17.5% or better (reclaims 60+ bps vs Q1), volume growth >9%, and management commentary flags fuel/coal cost moderation ahead. Stock rally on margin recovery narrative. Weak Q2: Revenue +12–16% YoY (volume miss), EBITDA margin dips to 16% or below (further 90+ bps compression), pricing power deteriorates in competitive regions (North India cement prices already soft in June), and guidance withdrawn or reset lower. Stock correction on structural margin pressure.
On Track for FY27 Guidance?
JK Cement guided for 22.5–23 MTPA grey cement for FY27, implying ~12–15% growth from FY26 base of ~20 MTPA. Q1 showed strong ramp (capacity now 32.26 MTPA live); Q2 should sustain momentum at ~8–10% YoY growth (in line with sector). On margins: FY26 EBITDA was not yet published in our data, but the Q1 drop to 16.07% suggests full-year pressure. If Q2 stabilizes at 17–18%, single-digit margin compression vs FY26 is still on plan. Capex guidance (FY27 ₹35–40bn) is tracking: 0.60 MnTPA wall putty plant commissioned Aug 2026, and ₹4.91 Cr invested in Mehrauni Electro Power (SPV for captive coal).
Recent Filings & Corporate Actions
Oct 6, 2026 — Shareholding: Kotak Mahindra Mutual Fund sold 304,671 shares (0.395% of the company), reducing its stake from 3.1935% to 2.7992%. Routine MF rebalance. Oct 6, 2026 — SBO Penalty: ROC fined JK Cement ₹4.72 lakhs for delays in Form BEN-2 (Significant Beneficial Owner disclosure). Compliance matter; voluntary application. Aug 12, 2026 — Expansion: Commissioned 0.60 MnTPA wall-putty plant at Nathdwara, Rajasthan (white-cement premiumization). July 29, 2026 — Investment: ₹4.91 Cr subscribed in Mehrauni Electro Power (captive-coal SPV), part of fuel-security strategy for FY30 50-MTPA target. July 11, 2026 — FIL stake increase: FMR LLC / FIL Ltd (Fidelity) raised holding to 9.17%, signalling institutional confidence in long-term expansion thesis.
Sector Backdrop for Q2
India's cement sector is facing margin pinch in Q2 despite solid volumes. Delayed monsoon extended construction season into June, boosting volumes (+8.5% expected YoY), but input costs (fuel, logistics) are rising faster than pricing power. North India cement prices were nearly flat Q-o-Q in April–May, then fell ~3% in June; South/Central hold better, but competition is stiff. The sector is reporting that price hikes are not fully covering cost inflation, a dynamic JK Cement signalled in Q1. Q2 will reveal whether that bottleneck persists or if labour/fuel cost moderation begins to show.
1 · Cement volume growth rate vs. expectations
Sector is expecting ~8.5% YoY for Q2. JK Cement has expanded capacity to 32.26 MTPA. A print >9% would signal strong market share gain; <8% would flag demand softness or mix headwind.
2 · EBITDA margin: stabilization or further compression
Q1 fell to 16.07% (down 444 bps YoY). If Q2 is 17%+, the street narrative shifts to 'tactical cost shock, recovery ahead.' If <16%, the story becomes structural margin pressure and FY27 guidance reset risk.
3 · Fuel and coal cost trends / pricing power commentary
Management guidance on petcoke/coal cost outlook for H2 FY27 will set tone. Any hint of stabilization or upside pricing power in newer capacity would support margin recovery narrative.
4 · FY27 capex and capacity ramp progress
Updates on the 7 MTPA North India greenfield and brownfield brownfield expansions (targeting 50 MTPA by FY30) will signal confidence in demand outlook and long-term margin potential.
Q2 FY27 is not about hitting a number; it is about durability. JK Cement has the volume story (22.5–23 MTPA guidance, capacity live, market share momentum). The real test is margins. Q1 showed that cement demand alone does not guarantee profit growth when input costs spike. Q2 verdict: if EBITDA margin holds at 17%+ and management sounds confident on H2 cost trajectory, the Street's +27% target case stays on. If margins slide further and guidance is muddied, repricing becomes likely. Price today ₹4,923, well below 52-week high ₹6,764.5 (−34.93%); the setup is bullish IF Q2 proves margin pressure is temporary.
Volume surge, margins caught in cost squeeze
Revenue jumped 23.7% YoY, but profit rose only 6.3%—and fell 38.4% QoQ. The quarter reveals a brutal mismatch: cost inflation is outpacing pricing power, and whether JK Cement recovers depends entirely on Q3 pricing discipline and new-venture losses narrowing.
₹3,733 Cr
+23.7% YoY
₹169 Cr
+6.3% YoY (mismatch to revenue)
₹500 Cr
−22% QoQ from ₹639 Cr
13.4%
vs 16.4% prior year
The headline reads like a blowout. Revenue up nearly a quarter on strong volume growth; PAT up 6%. But the gap between those two numbers is the entire story of Q2: cost inflation is eating profit faster than pricing can keep up. EBITDA fell 22% sequentially despite volumes holding firm. And the QoQ collapse in PAT—down 38.4% from Q1—tells you the damage is real and immediate, not a statistical artifact.
Where the margin compression came from
H1 volume growth is genuine: grey and white cement volumes combined are up 19% YoY. But coal and petcoke costs surged 55%, pushing the cost per Kcal to ₹1.71 in Q2. EBITDA tells the truth: Q2 EBITDA of ₹500 Cr is down 22% sequentially from ₹639 Cr in Q1, despite revenue being stable. The INR20 per bag price hike that JK pushed through mid-September translates to roughly ₹3–5 per ton of relief. But management explicitly stated the company still needs ₹10–15 more per ton to offset the fuel and coal headwinds forecast for Q3 and Q4.
The margin squeeze gets worse when you account for new businesses. Paint (JK Maxx) posted a loss of ₹2 Cr in Q2 on ₹116 Cr revenue. RMC (Ready-Mix Concrete) has 23 plants operational but zero EBITDA; each plant requires 3–4 months post-commissioning to break even. Together, paint and RMC are diluting consolidated margins by roughly 1.5–2%. Strip them out and core cement margins are under even more pressure.
Management's claims vs. what holds up
Cost peaked in Q2 at ₹1.71/Kcal; partial benefit coming in Q3
PAT down 38.4% QoQ; INR80–100 per ton cost headwinds extending into Q3–Q4. Peak unconfirmed.
Contradicted
Paint breakeven or positive EBITDA by FY27 end
Q2 loss ₹2 Cr on ₹116 Cr revenue. Breakeven likely requires ₹200+ Cr run-rate; timeline slipped to Q4 or beyond.
Partial (slipped)
H1 volumes +19%; guiding 23–24 MT for full FY27
Volumes tracking, but FY27 guidance maintained at 22.5–23 MT, not raised. No surprise on upside.
Overstated
Jasalmer, Bathinda capacity on track H1 FY28; Mahan moving ahead
Bathinda formal EC/CTE approvals 'expected shortly'; Jasalmer timeline holding. Mahan pushed to H1 FY29 (12m delay).
Partial
What changed from Q1
The Q1 call positioned INR150 per ton cost inflation as a Q2 peak. Now management signals INR80–100 per ton of headwinds will persist through Q3 and Q4—a material extension of margin pressure. Paint profitability has slipped by roughly 6 months: prior commentary hinted at breakeven by H1 FY27; now it's full-year end at best, conditional on scaling to ₹500–550 Cr revenue (already at ₹250 Cr H1, but losses continue). The Mahan coal block approval has been pushed back 12 months to H1 FY29, delaying the cost-structure refresh. Jasalmer and Bathinda remain H1 FY28 targets, but Bathinda still awaits formal letters from regulators.
Street positioning: the verdict the market is already rendering
The stock is trading at ₹4,888.5, down 35.4% from its all-time high of ₹7,565.5. It sits below its 20-day (₹4,923), 50-day (₹5,028), and 200-day (₹5,353) moving averages—a bearish setup. RSI at 46.4 is neutral, not oversold; the stock has found some support near its 52-week low of ₹4,671.5. What matters: foreign institutions have not fled. FII ownership is flat at 16.9%, DII unchanged at 23.7%, and promoters holding firm at 45.7%. The repricing is on fundamentals (margin compression), not on panic. This is a market that's waiting for catalysts, not giving up on the long-term story.
H1 volume growth 19% is genuine and healthy
40 MTPA by FY28 expansion on schedule (Jasalmer/Bathinda H1 FY28)
50 MTPA by FY30 thesis credible with ₹2,500 Cr yearly capex
PAT grew 6.3% YoY while revenue jumped 23.7%—cost pass-through breaking down
PAT down 38.4% QoQ; EBITDA down 22% QoQ despite stable volumes
Paint loss ₹2 Cr Q2; profitability 18–24 months out, not year-end
RMC at zero EBITDA at 23 plants; 3–4 months per plant to breakeven
Management opaque on segment margins—declined to disclose grey vs. white EBITDA/ton
Pricing power capped; ₹10–15 per ton hike may not stick in competitive market
Mahan coal block delayed to H1 FY29 (12-month slip); cost refresh pushed back
Risks ranked by severity for a holder
Input cost inflation extends into Q4; pricing power fails to keep up
HighINR80–100/ton power and fuel headwinds in Q3–Q4 are real. ₹10–15/ton price hikes may not clear market. If pricing stalls, EBITDA margin compresses below 12%, risking FY28 consensus.
Paint and RMC profitability timelines slip; consolidated margins dilute further
HighPaint loss ₹2 Cr Q2; RMC zero EBITDA. Combined drag ~1.5–2% of consolidated margin. If losses exceed ₹4 Cr in H1 or RMC ramp slows, PAT guidance at risk.
Capacity expansion delays (Bathinda approvals pending, Mahan 12m late)
MediumJasalmer/Bathinda slip past H1 FY28 weakens 40 MT thesis. Mahan delay to H1 FY29 pushes cost-structure refresh further out.
Segment profitability opacity; true margin health unknown
MediumNo grey vs. white cement EBITDA/ton disclosure. Makes it hard to judge whether premium product mix is holding pricing or whether core margins are worse than consolidated numbers imply.
Demand volatility (South drought, UP elections impact construction spend)
LowOnly ~15% of volumes exposed to drought regions. But monsoon failure in 2027 or post-election construction slowdown could soften demand.
1 · Q3 pricing power post-Diwali
Can JK Cement hold ₹10–15/ton price hikes, or does demand soften? If Q3 EBITDA margin falls below 12%, margin compression into FY28 is confirmed. If margin holds ≥13%, upside to ₹5,200 is plausible.
2 · Jasalmer and Bathinda commissioning on schedule (H1 FY28)
Execution on new capacity proves the 40 MT thesis is real. Any delays beyond H1 FY28 weaken the long-term thesis. Watch for 'formal letters' on Bathinda and Jasalmer ramp updates in Q3 guidance.
3 · Paint losses narrowing or widening in Q3–Q4
Q2 loss ₹2 Cr on ₹116 Cr revenue. If Q3–Q4 paint losses exceed ₹3–4 Cr combined, the 3–5% EBITDA margin target by FY28 is broken. Breakeven likely 18+ months away, not year-end.
JK Cement's Q2 is steady volume execution caught in an unresolved cost crisis. The 35% drawdown from all-time highs is justified by near-term margin compression, not by a broken long-term story. The capacity expansion thesis (40 MT by FY28, 50 MT by FY30) is real and underpinned by committed capex; that part of the bull case holds. But near-term recovery depends on pricing power in a competitive market, and Q2 shows that power is severely constrained.
For holders: Hold. You own the long-term thesis; don't add until Q3 shows evidence of pricing power inflecting and paint losses narrowing. FII/DII are not panicking, and promoters are holding firm—institutional positioning suggests confidence in recovery, just not in timing.
For potential buyers: the 35% drawdown is tempting, but wait for Q3. If margins hold above 12% EBITDA (a ₹450+ Cr print), upside to ₹5,200–5,500 is plausible on the long-term story. If margins slip below 11% EBITDA, re-test of ₹4,500–4,700 is likely on FY28 margin concerns.
The number to track: adjusted EBITDA per ton (the company won't disclose it). Analysts can triangulate it from segment guidance and quarterly updates. Below ₹400/ton and the 50 MT by FY30 thesis loses credibility. Above ₹450/ton in Q3 and the market re-rates upward. That single metric is the fulcrum of the debate.