Profit crater masks bullish multi-year thesis; execution risk high
The verdict, the claims that held up, the sharpest analyst exchanges, and the risks — the earnings call, decoded from the transcript.
Hold
confidence 6/10
Grade C
Incentives: ₹145 Cr (FY26) → ₹115 Cr (Q1 guidance) → ₹100 Cr (Q2 tracking). Capex: ₹500 Cr → ₹560 Cr FY27 (mid-year raise). Mixed track record.
Cautiously Optimistic
next 1–2 quarters
Optimistic
multi-year
Q2 profit plunged 44% YoY with revenue growth merely 2.5%, signaling severe margin compression from fuel cost inflation and incentive cuts. Management targets 12%-13% FY27 growth, but Q2 tracks at +5%, raising execution risk. Capex roadmap (₹3,000 Cr to 20 MT by 2030) is credible long-term, but near-term visibility poor and macro headwinds (coal inflation, competitive entry) unresolved.
₹831 Cr
Revenue · +2.5% YoY₹39.6 Cr
Reported PAT · −44.3% YoYCompressing
Margins · vs guidance: OverstatedDid the claims hold up?
FY27 cement volume growth 12%-13%
OVERSTATEDQ2 cement +5% YoY. Significantly below target trajectory.
H2 double-digit growth; pent-up demand to drive recovery
UnverifiedQ2 revenue +2.5% YoY; recovery unproven. October sample size too small.
Maintain good profitability despite cost pressures
MISSQ2 PAT -44% YoY, NPM 4.7%, OPM 18.5%. Per-ton EBITDA down 17%.
Capex FY27 ₹500 Cr
OVERSTATEDRevised to ₹560 Cr due to 6 MT Nimbol expansion decision.
Incentives ₹115 Cr for FY27 (from ₹145 Cr prior)
MISSQ2 ₹36 Cr + H2 guidance ₹65 Cr = ₹100 Cr total. Further cut.
Earnings quality
What changed since the last call
Capex FY27 raised
Upgrade₹500 Cr → ₹560 Cr; 6 MT Nimbol expansion (vs 5 MT) decision. FY28 ₹1,500 Cr unchanged.
Incentives cut further
DowngradePrior ₹115 Cr guidance tracking ₹100 Cr (Q2 ₹36 Cr + H2 ₹65 Cr est). Assam policy headwind.
Margin guidance implicit downgrade
DowngradePrior ₹1,500-1,600 Cr EBITDA FY27 now appears unrealistic given Q2 ₹164 Cr run rate.
H2 recovery outlook reaffirmed
NeutralOctober >12% demand cited; management confident pent-up demand will drive 12%-13% full-year.
The Q&A
Analysts challenged capex increases (raised ₹60 Cr), incentive cuts (₹115 → ₹100 Cr), and fuel cost sustainability. Management defended coal inventory (3-month stock), FSA ramps (60 rakes pending), and long-term optionality. Limited pushback on Q2 margin miss — tacit acceptance of near-term pain.
H2 demand recovery — Harsh Mittal, Emkay Global
PartialQ1-Q2 hit by elections and Assam monsoon. Q3-Q4 expect pent-up demand. October showed >12%. FY27 12%-13% guidance intact.
Capex and Nimbol — Shravan Shah, Dolat Capital
Answered6 MT Nimbol decided. EC approved. Ground-breaking Dec 2026, operational Jul-Aug 2028. Total capex ₹3,000 Cr within prior guidance.
Railway siding & fuel cost — Rajesh Ravi, HDFC
PartialRailway siding partial by January; power also partial. Fuel cost ₹1.52 Q2, ₹1.45 by March on FSA deliveries (60 rakes pending).
Fuel mix and Northeast competition — Navin Sahadeo, ICICI Securities
Partial3-month coal stock insulates from panic. FSAs ramping. Star 16-17% Northeast share. Competitors 2-3 years to build. Dominance persists long-term.
Clinker strategy — Shravan Shah, Dolat Capital
AnsweredClinker to non-branded grinding units (no direct Star competition). Non-branded market separate. Clinker pricing raised Q3 onward to reduce volume.
FY27 growth guidance credibility — Rajesh Ravi, HDFC
UnverifiedYes, 12%-13% intact. October >12%. H2 pent-up demand. Industry 7%-8%, Star >10% due to capacity/trade dominance.
Multi-year capacity roadmap — Vaibhav Agarwal, PhillipCapital
Answered18 MT by 2029-30, 20 MT by 2030-31. Nimbol Dec 2026 ground-break. Siliguri/Umrangso next 1-2 years. Clear pathway.
Guidance
FY27 cement volume 12%-13% growth
MediumQ2 only +5% YoY. H2 recovery assumption is untested. October >12% is supportive but narrow sample.
Capacity roadmap: 18 MT by FY29-30, 20 MT by FY30-31
HighNimbol EC approved. Siliguri, Umrangso, Jhajar in pipeline. Clear FY27-FY29 capex schedule ₹3,000 Cr.
EBITDA ₹1,500-1,600 Cr FY27 (prior guidance, implicitly softened)
LowQ2 ₹164 Cr → FY27 annualized ~₹656 Cr. H2 would need ₹844-944 Cr; unrealistic at current momentum.
Fuel cost ₹1.45/kcal by March 2027 (vs ₹1.55 prior expectation)
MediumQ2 ₹1.52/kcal actual. Coal inventory (3 months) + FSA ramps (60 rakes) provide downside. Global coal spike risk remains.
FY27 ₹560 Cr (raised from ₹500 Cr), FY28 ₹1,500 Cr, FY29 ₹610 Cr
MediumFY27 raise due to 6 MT Nimbol (vs 5 MT). FY28 ₹1,500 Cr for Siliguri, Umrangso, other projects. Multi-year flexibility built in.
Risks the call surfaced
Volume recovery execution
HighQ2 +5% growth contradicts 12%-13% full-year guidance. Assam floods, national elections, credit tightness all create demand headwinds. H2 recovery is the linchpin of FY27 thesis.
Margin compression from cost inflation
HighQ2 fuel cost ₹1.52/kcal; guidance ₹1.45 by March is aspirational. Global coal auction premiums are elevated (Coal India shortage cited). Per-ton EBITDA down 17% YoY.
Competitive capacity influx in Northeast
MediumStar holds 16-17% Northeast market share. Ambuja, JK, Shree all announcing 4-5 MT plants. Larger competitors with superior financial resources entering. Pricing power at risk despite Star's distribution moat.
Capex execution and project delays
Medium₹560 Cr FY27, ₹1,500 Cr FY28 capex plan dependent on EC clearances, land acquisition, labor availability. Nimbol pushed from prior timeline; Umrangso still under evaluation.
Incentive policy erosion
MediumAssam policy changed, slashing incentives: ₹145 Cr (FY26) → ₹115 Cr (Q1 guidance) → ₹100 Cr (Q2 tracking). Further policy shifts could compress profitability further.
Management
Score 6/10. MD Tushar Bhajanka articulate on strategy and detailed on capex; CFO Manoj Agarwal direct on financial specifics. Evasive on power cost per unit (initially deflected). Transparent on coal shortage and macro challenges. Incentive guidance missed twice (₹145 → ₹115 → ₹100 Cr); capex raised mid-year (₹500 → ₹560 Cr). Track record mixed; credibility weakened by multiple revisions.
1 · Q3-Q4 FY27
Pent-up demand post-monsoon/elections; management targeting double-digit volume growth
2 · Jan 2027
Sikilchar railway siding partly operational; fly ash cost benefits begin
3 · Dec 2026
Nimbol (Rajasthan) ground-breaking for 3.3 MT clinker capacity
Capex roadmap (₹3,000 Cr to 20 MT by 2030) is credible long-term, but near-term visibility poor and macro headwinds (coal inflation, competitive entry) unresolved.
Informational and educational content only. Not investment advice.